r. Richard Lee was born in Islip,
New York, on May 26, 1937. He went to public schools
through the eighth grade and then to private schools,
including a year at Loretto School in Scotland. He then
went to Yale University, graduating in 1960. He was a
member of the Torch Honor Society and president of the
Interfraternity Council. He then went to Yale University
Medical School, graduating in 1964 cum laude, and was a
member of Alpha Omega Alpha. He did his internship,
residency in medicine, and fellowship in infectious
disease at Yale-New Haven Hospital. Intermingled in his
residency was a 2-year tour with the US Public Health
Service at the Fort Peck Indian Reservation in Poplar,
Montana, followed by a year in general practice in
Chester, Montana.
After completing his fellowship in
June 1971, Dr. Lee remained at Yale University, where he
was director of medical clinics and later director of the
Primary Care Center. He rose to the rank of associate
professor of clinical medicine and chief of general
medicine of Yale University. He left New Haven in July
1996 to become professor and vice chairman of the
Department of Medicine at State University of New York at
Buffalo and chief of medical service at Buffalo Veterans
Administration Medical Center. He's been in Buffalo ever
since. In 1979 he became head of the Department of
Medicine of Children's Hospital of Buffalo and remained
in that position until 1997. Since he's been in Buffalo
he's picked up a number of other responsibilities in and
outside of that city, including chief of the Division of
Maternal and Adolescent Medicine and the Division of
Geographic Medicine in the Department of Medicine at
State University of New York at Buffalo; professor of
pediatrics; consultant in internal medicine to the
Buffalo Zoological Society at the Buffalo Zoo (Figure 1);
adjunct professor of anthropology and social and
preventive medicine at State University of New York at
Buffalo; medical director of Ecology and Environment,
Inc.; and chief medical officer of the WHO Center for
Health in Housing, State University of New York at
Buffalo.
He has published extensively, including 75 articles in
peer-reviewed medical journals; 151 essays, editorials,
and commentaries; 9 books; and 62 chapters in books
edited by other authors. A review of the titles of his
editorials and essays shows the diversity of his mind.
William Clifford Roberts, MD (hereafter, WCR): I
am with Dr. Richard Lee in my office at Baylor University
Medical Center on March 28, 2000. Dr. Dick Lee just gave
a presentation at medical grand rounds entitled
Gestational delights: what internists need to know
about pregnancy. Dr. Lee, I sincerely appreciate
the opportunity to talk with you. Your presentation at
medical grand rounds was wonderful. Your presentation at
the medical residents conference in an hour or so is
entitled The dance to the music of time. Dr.
Lee recently was guest editor of a symposium on time
published in the January 2000 issue of The Annals of
Internal Medicine. Dr. Lee, could we begin by discussing
your early life, your parents, your siblings, and some of
your early memories?
Richard Vaille Lee, MD (hereafter, RVL): I was
born in Long Island, New York, in 1937. At the age of 5,
following Pearl Harbor, my father who was then 38 or 39
tried desperately to get into military service, but he
was too old, wore glasses, and had flat feet, so he wound
up in officer training for the US Army and was assigned
to the Army Air Force, which had a major training command
in Fort Worth, Texas. Thus, from 1941 to the middle of
1946, I lived in Fort Worth. Then we moved back to Long
Island and then to New England. My father was a building
contractor and a very good one. Although trained as an
early childhood teacher, my mother was a housewife.
When I became a recalcitrant adolescent, I was sent
off to boarding school at the age of 12 or 13. I spent 5
years in boarding schools--4 in the USA and 1 in the
United Kingdom. I then went to Yale and to Yale Medical
School and stayed at Yale for housestaff training.
Between my second and third year of residency, we lived
in Montana for 3 years: the first 2 years I was a Public
Health Service officer in the Indian Health Service on
the Fort Peck Indian Reservation, and the third year I
was in private practice in Chester, Montana, with an old
friend who had also gone to Yale. I returned in 1969 to
New Haven to finish my residency, followed by an
infectious disease fellowship. Then I was asked to take
over the outpatient program for the Department of
Medicine. I did that until 1976, when I was recruited by
Evan Calkins (an interesting rheumatologist) to the State
University of New York at Buffalo. I have been in Buffalo
ever since, doing a whole lot of different things,
basically trying to stay out of trouble and not always
successfully.
WCR: What is your title at Buffalo?
RVL: I am a professor. I have been chief of
medicine at the Veterans Affairs Medical Center and then
at the Children's Hospital, which was also the major
maternity hospital in town. That is where my interest in
obstetric medicine really developed, although I became
interested in it at Yale. The medical service at Yale for
years had a joint clinic with the obstetrical service. It
was started by John Peters (of Peters and van Slyke fame)
and then continued by Frank Epstein. Even when I was a
senior medical student and an intern, I was the
dirty old man in that I was interested in
infectious disease. I was the person asked to see the
pregnant ladies with unusual infections, which often
turned out to be sexually transmitted diseases. At the
end of my first year of residency, moving to the Indian
reservation, I became a general practitioner and
delivered babies as part of that. When we moved to
Chester after 2 years, I delivered our second son because
my partner had gone off to a meeting in Hawaii.
As far as my family background goes, I thought I was a
normal child of a middle-class Caucasian family until
1961, when I advised my parents that I wanted to marry my
wife. My father told me that his father, my grandfather,
was Chinese. His name was Li Yan Phou. Li Yan Phou was
part of an experiment in international education. The
first Chinese person to graduate from a US college was
Yung Wing, who graduated from Yale in the 1850s. He
returned to China and became an important person in civil
service and in educational circles and finally convinced
the declining power of the Qing dynasty to create the
Chinese Educational Mission, an experiment. The Americans
agreed to this as well. Every year for 4 years, 30 boys
would be selected by examination to come to the USA and
be educated in English and in American technology,
including military schools. They would then return to
China to help transform China from a feudal empire into a
modern empire.
My grandfather was in the second group of boys. He was
born about 1861 or 1862 and arrived in the USA at the age
of 12. The boys were taken to the Hartford/Springfield
area, where they were placed with families. The family
that my grandfather was placed with was named Vaille. The
Vaille family provided a home for two or three of these
youngsters. They became very American. My grandfather
went to the Hopkins grammar school, a private grammar
school in New Haven, and then went to Yale. However,
after his freshman year, which would have been in 1881,
the United States refused to allow the Chinese boys to
enter the military academies, either Annapolis or West
Point. Many of the boys had dropped their Chinese dress
and shaved their Manchu queues; some of them had become
Christian. The Imperial government disapproved, elected
to retract the program, and recalled the students.
Of the 120 boys, 119 returned to China. One of the
boys (not my grandfather) hid in the basement of the
Vaille house and managed to escape the recall. My
grandfather returned to China and for 3 years was
assigned to the navy, which he hated. He managed to
escape to Hong Kong and then returned to the USA, where
he reentered Yale and completed his degree, married a
very prominent American woman, and had a series of
misadventures. This marriage ended in divorce. He then
married a second American woman, my grandmother. My
grandfather was an editor of some journals and
newspapers. He did a variety of things. It was clear that
his brilliance as a student at Yale was not being
recognized--partly because he was Chinese and partly
because of his own internal flaws. He returned to China
in 1927 and died around 1939, we think, during the
bombing by the Japanese of Canton, which is where he had
resettled. I never knew him. I knew his second wife, my
grandmother, and I knew my uncle, who was 4 or 5 years
older than my father.
My father went to Yale, graduating in 1927. It was
after he graduated that my grandfather returned to China.
My father's older brother had gone to Annapolis and was a
captain in the US Navy. To give you some idea of the
anti-Chinese sentiment, here was an Annapolis graduate,
captain of a major vessel in the navy, based in San
Diego, who wanted to marry a Caucasian woman. In the
1930s, a Chinese man could not legally marry a Caucasian
woman in California. He had to go to Yuma, Arizona, to
get married. Neither my father nor my uncle spoke very
much about their Chinese background or their father.
So, in 1961, I was told that I was part Chinese and
that this had been a very carefully kept family secret
because of anti-Chinese sentiment and prejudices.
Nevertheless, historically it's very interesting because
it was one of the first real entrances into the modern
world by the Chinese Imperial government. Indeed, a
number of the students in that program went on to build
its infrastructure. (A couple of them were responsible
for constructing the railway system. A number were
responsible for the ports and the development of commerce
and shipping services in China.) They accomplished a
great deal.
WCR: Why did your grandfather return to
China in 1927?
RVL: We were never really sure. I think the
marriage to his second wife was a difficult one. I don't
think his relationships with his 2 sons were all that
good. My uncle was a captain in the navy; my father had
an engineering degree from Yale and was working for a
building contractor that built mansions for the very
wealthy of New England. I think there may have been a
little bit of embarrassment that there was this Chinese
figure hovering in the background. In any case, he did
return to China and we basically lost contact. It's now
interesting when I return to China, which I do as part of
the China Association, and I say my grandfather was
Chinese. They look at me and they laugh. They say,
You're not Chinese. I don't really look
Chinese. My father married a Caucasian woman. Going back
through his Yale College photographs and class books, he
clearly looks somewhat Asian, not distinctly Asian, but I
would never have noticed it until he told me. My uncle
was known as Chink; his nickname was
Chink Lee at Annapolis. That's our family
background; we had this deep, dark secret, which turns
out not to be so deep or dark and actually is something
that I find quite honorable and unique.
WCR: How many siblings do you have?
RVL: There were three of us. I had an older
brother and a younger sister. My older brother, who was 4
years older than I, died in 1956 flying jets for the Air
Force. Both my uncle and my father served in World War
II, and my brother enlisted in the Air Force just as the
Korean War was ending and died in an accident. My sister,
who is 7 years younger than I am, was born in Fort Worth
and now lives in Rhode Island. She was trained as a
nurse. There has always been a heavy emphasis in my
family on providing service to people--either service to
your country or service to people. It was ingrained in
us.
My parents' deaths are interesting. They were in their
early 80s, and my mother had developed multi
small-infarct dementia and my father was developing
macular degeneration. They were living in Florida, a long
way away from both my sister and me. It was clear that
they were not in a very tenable circumstance, in terms of
being totally independent. At some point my father
planned my mother's death and his suicide, which they
accomplished in 1989.
WCR: Was your father ill?
RVL: No. His eyesight was failing, and he had
some mild hypertension. I think he was in the situation
of losing his independence. It was beginning to be
difficult for him to drive and drive safely. That would
have been a major problem. These were fiercely
independent folks. They would not have tolerated a
nursing home.
WCR: Your mother died first?
RVL: Yes. He killed her and then he killed
himself.
WCR: How old was she?
RVL: She was 83 and he was 86.
WCR: How did you handle that? Did you
interpret that as your father doing both of them a favor?
RVL: I think so. It's hard to give a straight
answer. I knew that something was brewing. We talked
frequently on the telephone and we tried to visit often.
They were living in the Orlando area. I think it was the
only way to solve what he thought was a dreadful problem.
His comment always had been that they were never going to
be a burden to their children. They weren't.
WCR: You consider that an honorable death or
a good death?
RVL: I think so. Their relationship was
becoming increasingly strained because my mother was
becoming increasingly demented. My father was an
assiduous and compassionate caretaker, but as his vision
failed he could not continue to care for her. We talked
about setting up some kind of living arrangement for them
that would be close to us. He elected not to do that. I
still haven't figured it all out or digested it
completely. But I don't think it was something that was
evil.
WCR: What was your home life like when you
were growing up? Did you have intellectual discussions
around the dinner table?
RVL: Not really. From the age of about 12 or
13, I was away at school, and that was a good experience
for me. I was the only one of the kids who was sent off.
I think that was probably because I was the most
difficult. I was always giving them trouble. My father
had this notion of self-reliance, that you had to learn
how to do it yourself. If you can't do it yourself, then
that's your problem. That is the way things developed.
WCR: Your father was successful financially?
You didn't have to worry about money growing up?
RVL: No, I did not.
WCR: How did you get interested in medicine?
Were there any physicians in your family?
RVL: No. My grandfather came from a Mandarin
family, a professional family where scholarship and
service were key. I think my parents always wanted me to
be a physician. My brother's entrance into the military,
becoming a jet fighter pilot, probably took them by
surprise. I think they expected him to become an
engineer. I was going to be a doctor and my sister was
going to be a nurse and a housewife. They had that
planned. In my senior year at Yale I had already won a
fellowship in biology. I was very interested in
experimental biology. My interest in medical school, I
still have not figured out. I think my father
orchestrated part of that. I only applied to Yale. I knew
the president of Yale at that time, Whitney Griswold. He
and I had spoken and had actually done some work together
that he was pleased about. I have a suspicion that
somehow it was brought up that I should go to Yale
Medical School and President Griswold called the
admission office and said, He's going to apply and
you're going to take him.
WCR: How did you know President Griswold?
RVL: In the mid 1950s there were still
fraternities at Yale. President Griswold was not kindly
disposed to fraternities. Fraternities at that time still
carried out a variety of high jinx, which involved
drinking and hazing and a few other things, recurring
themes in terms of popularity. I became the president of
what was known as the Interfraternity Council. It was my
responsibility to respond to President Griswold's
criticism. He wanted to abolish fraternities altogether.
Yale has a very strong history of fraternal
organizations, ranging from the secret societies in the
senior year to regular fraternities like Delta Kappa
Epsilon. We worked out a deal. We would stop pledging
rituals; the fraternities would continue to exist, but
they basically would be civilized institutions as opposed
to uncivil institutions.
WCR: No hazing?
RVL: No hazing, no pledging, and no public
displays of tomfoolery, which I think President Griswold
found rather embarrassing. He was very grateful for that.
It worked out very well. He did not get accused of being
antifraternal, and he accomplished the goal of making
sure that Yale misbehavior would not reach the public
press on a regular basis.
WCR: Did you know Bill Buckley?
RVL: Bill graduated in 1952 and I didn't get to
Yale until 1956. I did not know him.
WCR: Who influenced you in junior high, high
school, and college? Did you have any mentors who helped
in your development?
RVL: I'm sure I did. I'm not exactly sure that
there was any one who stood out as being the only one or
the principal one. I was sent off to a boarding school
called St. Paul's School in Concord, New Hampshire. I was
a child from an outside family. There were several
faculty who took a particular interest in me and who I
found enjoyable. Then I was sent off to a school in
Scotland called the Loretto School, one of the few
Scottish boarding schools. This was in 1955, and Britain
was still very much recovering from World War II and the
Korean conflict. There had never been anybody who was not
a subject of the queen who had gone to the school. I was
this strange American creature. That, I think, influenced
me a great deal. I made a lot of good friends. I got to
know a number of the faculty, and I still stay in contact
with several of them. One of the teachers there, a
delightful gentleman who was the English master, is still
alive (he's now 80), and we just visited him in Scotland
3 or 4 weeks ago. He retired from Loretto. Our oldest son
also spent a year at Loretto. He was taught by Mr. Wood.
Then Mr. Wood retired and we arranged and financed his
spending a year as a visiting teacher at the private day
school that our second son was attending. Mr. Wood taught
2 generations of Lees. We still keep in contact with him.
WCR: Did your father recommend Loretto to
you?
RVL: No. Actually during my senior year the
headmaster of St. Paul's had just spent 6 months on
sabbatical and had visited the school and was most
impressed. I think my parents conspired with him to say,
Lee needs to have a little more finishing. I
got shipped off. It was probably an experiment on the
part of the 2 schools, as well as something to satisfy my
parents.
WCR: Were you an athlete?
RVL: Yes. I played ice hockey at St. Paul's and
at Yale--not for very long because I kept getting hurt.
It was too expensive: You're always getting
stitches, Lee.
WCR: What did you study at college?
RVL: I majored in zoology. I was very fortunate
when I was at Loretto. The British system is 13 years, as
opposed to 12 years of undergraduate school in the USA.
It was 13 years of grammar school and high school and
then 3 years of university training. We do 12 and 4. When
I was at Loretto I was able to take what was known as the
A level examinations, which I did in biology, chemistry,
and English. I got credit for those. By the time I got to
the second half of my junior year of college, I had
already fulfilled the requirements for the zoology major.
I started taking history, philosophy, and religion
courses, which were terrific. Those were great fun. In my
senior year I think I only took 1 course, an honors
seminar.
WCR: How did you enjoy medical school?
RVL: I had a ball in medical school. I must
tell you that my undergraduate career at Yale had a very
ill start. I flunked several courses--partly because I
was having a really good time and partly because I wasn't
very smart. My entrance into medical school, after being
friends with the president of the university, was highly
beneficial. I found medical school terrific. The Yale
system at that time considered students as scholars and
expected them to study. We didn't have a lot of
examinations. We had to write papers, we had to do
demonstrations, and we had to pass the national boards. I
became a prosector in the anatomy lab. I did anatomy
dissections all 4 years in medical school.
I think my medical school teachers probably were my
major influence. Averill Liebow was professor of
pathology, a remarkable man, somewhat napoleonic. Alvan
Feinstein, who is still a professor at Yale, was just
beginning his series of clinical judgment and clinical
epidemiology studies. He became an enormous influence.
Paul Beeson, who was chairman of the Department of
Medicine, was another influence. One of the articles in
the January 2000 issue of The Annals of Internal
Medicine is an interview I did with Paul a year ago.
He was 90 then, and he was reminiscing about his career
in medicine, which was remarkable. We still correspond
fairly often. There were a lot of heroes in the old
medical school at that time.
The one thing I found most fascinating about Yale was
how accessible the faculty were. We were able to walk in
on Elisha Atkins, Howard Spiro, or Jerry Klatskin, to go
to their office and say, We have this interesting
case. Can you help? If there is a big difference
between medical education in 2000 and medical education
in 1960, I think it has to do with how accessible the
faculty are and how often we had dealings with them. I
sometimes think that part of our difficulties with
medical education today has to do with the retraction of
the faculty, particularly the clinical faculty, into
their laboratories and their scholarship as opposed to
their teaching activities.
WCR: You enjoyed the medical arena in New
Haven so well that you decided to do your houseofficer's
training there also. Did you have any problem deciding
what area of medicine you wanted to go into?
RVL: Yes, I did. It was terrible. I enjoyed the
whole thing. When I became a third-year student, my first
rotation was surgery. Gustave Lindskog was chairman of
the Department of Surgery. I had been a surgical clerk
for about 10 days when one of his interns developed
active tuberculosis and was sent off to a sanatorium. I
was it, and I became the surgical intern. This was with
10 days of clinical experience, and I can assure you that
it was a most trying but exciting time. I learned a
tremendous amount of surgery, and I liked surgery a lot.
I liked medicine; I liked obstetrics. The whole thing was
just tremendous fun and very challenging.
In the summer between my third and fourth years, my
wife and I went to Chester, Montana, where a man who had
graduated from Yale around 1945 or 1946 was a general
practitioner. Chester is in the middle of nowhere. It's
along Route 2, between Shelby and Havre, not particularly
notable cities. Chester has a population of about 1000
and a little hospital. I spent the summer working with
Dr. Richard Buker. I did everything from surgery to
deliveries to house calls to ambulance calls, riding
across the Montana prairie in an ambulance at 80 miles an
hour for automobile accidents. It was kind of nuts but an
exciting time.
I finally decided on internal medicine, and I became
an intern with Dr. Beeson. At the end of my internship
year, Dr. Beeson became the Nuffield Professor at Oxford.
We had an interim chair for a while, and then Phillip
Bondy became our chair. Our group of interns has always
had a particular affection for Dr. Beeson. We still meet
with him periodically. This was in the middle of the
Vietnam conflict. I enlisted in the Public Health Service
with a commission and went off to the Indian Health
Service.
WCR: After your internship?
RVL: After my first year of residency, I stayed
the extra year as a general practitioner with Dr. Buker,
whose partner had left him. He was alone. It was very
difficult for me to say, Well, I really have to go
back and finish my residency. So I said, I'll
come work with you for a year so that you can recruit
somebody to come and join you, and then I'll go back and
do my residency. At that time I was already older
to begin with, so I was another year older and had some
unusual experiences compared with the other members of
the housestaff team.
WCR: You finished your fellowship in
infectious disease.
RVL: I finished residency in 1970 and was a
fellow in 1971. When still a fellow, I became the
director of the medical clinics and the emergency room
for the Department of Medicine.
WCR: What appealed to you about infectious
disease?
RVL: Elisha Atkins, Paul Beeson, and Barry Wood
had been studying the genesis of fever. This was before
we got to the point where we could dissect leukocyte
hormones as well as we do now. It was clear that we
understood that there was something that was being
produced by white cells--exactly which kind of white cell
wasn't clear. It turned out it was lymphocytes, not
polys. I was intrigued by that. Experimental medicine was
quite fun. Another of Dr. Beeson's fellows, Larry
Freedman, and another of the housestaff described the
animal model for endocarditis (the idea of putting a
catheter in the vein, leaving it there, letting a
platelet clot form, and then injecting bacteria to
produce a vegetation). All of these things were going on,
and they were really quite exciting. That is how I got
interested in infectious disease, which is not organ
oriented. Having decided to go into medicine, as opposed
to surgery, that was the first step. Surgery was
increasingly becoming organ oriented. I must say that I
found that there were so many different things about
medicine, about the medical enterprise, that it was tough
to say I'm only going to do one thing.
WCR: You liked the variety.
RVL: Yes.
WCR: How did it come about that you took
charge of the outpatient clinics in the Department of
Medicine at Yale?
RVL: I was just a kid at that point, even
though I was 32. I'd been a real doctor for 3 years,
working on the Fort Peck Indian Reservation. There were
two of us there to take care of a population of probably
10,000 people, plus the villagers (non-Indian people who
lived in the towns) in an area about the size of the
state of Connecticut. We had to do everything. After the
first year I became the officer in charge, putting
together programs to provide care for a widely dispersed
rural population. I organized and ran 2 different
clinics. When I got back to Yale I was this strange
creature who had actually done some things, not in the
military, not with some other organization that was
directly telling me how to do things, but having to do
some things that were creative. I was asked, Why
don't you do this, because you know what it's like to be
a doctor in the outpatient department? That is how
I got to know Mike Emmett, because Mike came in
1971, my first year.
We organized the outpatient rotations so that most of
the outpatient experience in terms of emergency room and
urgent clinics was done during a 5- to 6-month period of
the first year of residency. I had a group, about half of
the first-year residents, for 5 or 6 months. This meant
that they had intensive exposure to ambulatory
medicine--through the emergency room to the urgent clinic
and to the follow-up clinics to make sure that patients
were actually taking their hypertensive medication. At
the same time, it was very much an integral part of the
inpatient service. I used to have outpatient morning
report, just like they had inpatient morning report. We'd
go up and we'd actually go see the patients they had
admitted from the emergency room to see how they were
doing and to see what was happening. I still think of it
fondly as one of the best ways to teach real
honest-to-goodness outpatient medicine in relation to
what happens to patients when they get sick and have to
go to the hospital, how you keep them out of the
hospital, or how you manage them over a long period of
time. All first-year residents would establish a cadre of
patients, which they would then continue to follow for
the rest of their housestaff career. They would come down
and they'd see patients once a week. These were patients
that they had seen in the emergency room or the urgent
care visit. We did not assign patients to them who had
been long-term patients. It was their patients that they
had taken care of and they were responsible for.
WCR: It must have been difficult for you to
leave Yale. You'd been there for a long time; you grew up
mainly in the northeast corridor of the country. How did
the Buffalo opportunity come about, and what made you
leave Yale?
RVL: Part of it was that Yale was beginning to
change a lot. A lot of my heroes, as it were, were now
aging faculty or faculty who would not be continuing on
for a long period of time. Phil Bondy had resigned as
chairman; there was an interim chairman, and then Sam
Thier became chairman. Sam and I are almost identical in
age and almost diametrically opposite in philosophy. It
was apparent that it would be to my advantage and to
Sam's advantage for us to part company, which we did and
reasonably amicably.
WCR: How has it worked out in Buffalo?
You've been in Buffalo since 1976.
RVL: It's been terrific. I've enjoyed it. I
guess I'm a little bit like my father: I like my
independence. I found the Veterans Affairs system
difficult to deal with. I think they found me difficult
to deal with as well. I had problems accepting the notion
that you limit the outpatient visits so you can have a
budget surplus that you can use for other kinds of
things. I thought our purpose for being there was to take
care of patients, not to deal with budgetary
manipulation. Ultimately, there was proven to be some
criminal activity on the part of the administration level
at the Buffalo Veterans Affairs Medical Center, which I
became aware of, and I found it difficult to be a
good ol' boy. It was better for me to get
out.
WCR: You went to the Children's Hospital.
What was your experience there?
RVL: I was chief of medicine at Children's
Hospital, which is basically a pediatric hospital and a
maternity hospital.
WCR: When did that begin?
RVL: That began in 1979, just 3 years after I
moved to Buffalo. That worked out very nicely. My
interest in obstetric medicine and medical complications
of pregnancy became much more fully developed. I
recruited some young folks who continue to practice with
me and who continue to be interested in the care of
pregnant patients. We left the Children's Hospital 3 or 4
years ago to set up our own office. They are in private
practice; I'm still a part of the university, but they
cross-cover me. They help me with my patients. I don't
help them very much at all. They are pretty independent
at this point. That was a very productive time. We did a
lot of things--published a number of papers, developed a
teaching program for the American College of Physicians,
edited some books. It's turned out to be great fun.
WCR: You are teaching
at the American College of Physicians what internists
should know about complications of pregnancy?
RVL: Right. We get a fair number of young folks
who come because they want to go into practice, and they
are going to be asked to see pregnant patients. They
don't get a lot of exposure in their housestaff training
programs in terms of how to deal with that and what to
expect.
WCR: You mentioned that you really got
interested in the care of pregnant women when you were at
Yale. How did that come about?
RVL: John Peters, who had been one of the
professors of medicine at Yale, had established a joint
clinic with the obstetrical service where patients with
renal disease, patients with hypertension, a variety of
problems, were seen jointly by the obstetricians and the
internists. Frank Epstein and Jerry Burrow continued
that. I was asked to participate in it because of my
interest in infectious disease and sexually transmitted
diseases. I would go up every so often and see patients
who had funny kinds of skin lesions or had fevers or had
difficult problems that the obstetricians wanted some
help with. That's how that got started.
WCR: For nearly 20 years you took care of
babies and pregnant women?
RVL: Yes.
WCR: What are you doing now?
RVL: I still see consults. I'm 63 on my next
birthday. Things are changing quickly. I don't think that
I can be intelligent about the breadth of medicine that
interests me. There's a limit on how many journals I can
subscribe to and read. There are some trends in medical
research that I find hard to comprehend. Some of the
statistical machinations that are used in papers nowadays
strike me as being particularly difficult. I worry that
we've really started to take care of numbers as opposed
to patients. I try to limit my practice to some patients
I have followed for a long time and to new consults with
medical complications of pregnancy. The other area of
interest that I've had for a long time is international
health and tropical medicine. I see a number of patients
who have travel-related illnesses or unusual diseases. I
still like to think of myself as a diagnostician, an
old-fashioned notion that has gone out of style, I think,
in internal medicine. I find that to be fun. My scholarly
activity has to do with working with isolated
communities. In the summer we go off to the Himalayas or
the Brazilian Amazon region or the northwest frontier
province of Kenya, working with groups of humans who have
lived far away from lots of things (Figure 2, Figure 3, Figure 4, and
Figure 5).
WCR: What do you do when you get there?
RVL: We weigh them, measure them, listen to
their complaints, and try to treat those who can be
treated in a short period of time. It's usually simple
kinds of things--mainly acute infections. We are really
interested in how they live their lives and what their
environment does in terms of their illness patterns.
There's a remarkable similarity among all these different
groups, although they live in different environments, in
terms of the major problems that they are confronted
with. Most of their problems have to do with infection
and trauma. I don't know that we really help them a whole
lot, other than the fact that we may prevent some
deafness in kids who have repetitive ear infections. We
can treat them a little bit with antibiotics and get
their ears cleared up. We can immunize.
WCR: Who funds these activities?
RVL: We've had various grant support in
different ways: the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention, Pan American Health Organization, World
Health Organization. What I do now is say that I'm going,
and if people want to come with me they have to pay their
own way. We do this like Earthwatch does: people pay
their own way and participate in the program. We have
supported 3 anthropology graduate students, who have
produced 2 or 3 papers out of each expedition.
WCR: How long is an expedition?
RVL: About 31/2 weeks.
WCR: How much time do you take off a year?
RVL: The longer I'm gone, the better the dean
likes it. I'm gone from Buffalo for these kinds of things
usually 5 weeks at a time.
WCR: So you are gone about 3 months a year?
RVL: About that.
WCR: Are you on salary?
RVL: I get part of a salary from the
university. I have to figure out how to do the rest of it
myself.
WCR: When you see private patients do you
charge them?
RVL: Yes, but the money goes to the university.
WCR: What do you enjoy doing the most?
RVL: That changes as I change. I enjoy being a
bedside clinical teacher the most. Now, I don't do as
much of that. I enjoy talking with different kinds of
students a lot. I teach a course called geographic
medicine with one of the anthropology professors. That is
mostly for graduate students in geography, anthropology,
and nursing. They seem to draw on this experience that
I've been doing that tries to put where and how people
live in perspective with illness and health. It is a very
popular course and it's great fun.
WCR: You teach that in college.
RVL: Right. This is for graduate students, and
a few undergraduate students in the honors program take
it as well.
WCR: How long have you been doing that?
RVL: About 6 or 7 years. And then I do my stint
as a ward attending. I ward attend 2 to 3 months of the
year. I take morning report at one of the teaching
hospitals every week, 1 day a week. I have a couple of
clinics that I do for obstetric patients. And I see a few
private patients.
WCR: What do you do at night when you get
home?
RVL: All sorts of things. I like to write. I
spend a fair amount of my time at home writing, reading,
and thinking. We have an empty nest so it is just Susan,
my wife, and me. We go to concerts and plays.
WCR: So it's spent in scholarly endeavors?
RVL: Yes. We live on a farm, and we've managed
to scrape up enough money to convert one of the barns
into an office, which is fairly capacious, to which I can
retreat. It's a little bit like a Chinese scholar's
retreat. That is where I spend a fair amount of time
doing scholarly type things, ranging from preparing talks
to writing papers.
WCR: You have how many children?
RVL: Two.
WCR: What do they do?
RVL: Our oldest son is the State Department
correspondent for the French international news agency.
He went to Georgetown University and, like his father,
had a dilatory college career but managed to graduate and
then went into journalism. He worked at the Washington
Post and then in Charlottesville, Virginia, at the Daily
Progress. After he got dumped by one of his
girlfriends, he said, I'm going to get out of here.
I want to go as far away as I can. So he cashed in
some stock and went to Phnom Penh, Cambodia. He was there
for 4 years and became the bureau chief for the French
news agency. He decided that it was time to come home,
and he went to Washington, DC, and became a State
Department correspondent. I don't know where he is right
now, probably at home. But he has been off with Mrs.
Albright and Mr. Clinton in their India/Pakistan trip. He
is not married. I don't think he can be married to
anybody since he has no schedule. He goes at the whim of
the State Department.
My younger son, Ben, went to Yale. (It's always been
second sons who have gone to Yale.) He returned to China.
He became one of the English-language fellows that Yale
sends to various parts of China to teach English for 2
years. He was in Wuhan for 2 years. His Mandarin is quite
good. He spent a year teaching English in Japan and then
came back to New Haven and was working for the Yale China
Association that started out about 100 years ago.
Part of the connection is obviously my father and
grandfather and our Chinese connection. In the late 1890s
there was the Boxer Rebellion. One of the
victims of the Boxer Rebellion was a Yale graduate,
Horace Pitkin, who was beheaded by the Boxers. His Yale
classmates decided that Yale needed to do something about
that. They established the Yale China Association, which
was responsible for constructing a school that actually
became part of Yale that would award Yale degrees in
Changsha, the capital of the Hunan Province. They also
started a medical school there. Yale continued to send
faculty and nurses. There's a nursing school there as
well. That continued until 1949 when the communists took
over and threw everybody out. Yale China then began to
work in Hong Kong. In 1979 or 1980, the Chinese reopened
the connection with the Yale China Association. Since
that time we have been sending medical people and taking
Chinese medical scholars at Yale. Ben got involved with
that and then I became involved. I am now a trustee and
secretary of the Board of Trustees of the Yale China
Association. That's been a very rewarding, long-term
family-related connection.
WCR: Of all the things you've done, what are
you most proud of?
RVL: I've never been asked that question. I
don't know the answer to that. I think probably the fact
that Susan and I are still married and we've got 2 kids
who are self-sufficient.
WCR: What do you want to do from here on?
RVL: Continue to have fun. I think medicine is
tremendous fun. I get worried that sometimes it's being
converted into a job as opposed to a profession and that
people may not have as much fun as I had.
WCR: What is your advice to a young person
who wants to go into medicine?
RVL: Do it. Don't make too many decisions too
early.
WCR: What does that mean?
RVL: I see a lot of kids in medical school who
have already decided they are going to be a radiologist
or an ophthalmologist. There's far too much fun stuff in
medicine. I think doctoring is quintessential
anthropology. We study humankind. I think that it is
terribly important that we keep that in mind. At the
morning report which I just took here at Baylor
University Medical Center, one of the houseofficers
presented an elderly black man who has chronic renal
failure and who had been living at home with his mother
who is 85. He comes in covered with junk and feces. My
comment was, Well, what is happening to his mom?
And what's been happening at home to make him come in so
unable to take care of himself? I really think that
is part of what we should be doing as
doctors--understanding how our patients got to be the way
they are. Making home visits, for example, is really
important. But we don't do it. And we don't teach people
how to do it. The houseofficer said, I can't take
all the equipment that I need to provide the care.
I said, The only thing you need is yourself--some
eyes and a curiosity that will help you decide what to do
for the patient. The reason for going into the home
is not to cure somebody but to understand the patient
better. We've gotten used to the idea that medicine cures
things rather than understands things. That may be a bold
generalization. I think we have been sold a bill of goods
by our therapeutic triumphs. There is still a role for
the doctor to hold hands.
WCR: How does molecular biology fit into
your scheme of things?
RVL: I think it is absolutely fascinating! Just
because it is molecular biology doesn't mean that it
doesn't have a human face. However, it takes a special
mind-set to practice clinical medicine with molecular
biology in mind. And as part of your armamentarium, it
requires a breadth of understanding that I worry whether
we really give to our students. The things that are
happening in molecular biology are just fascinating, but
they have a human face.
WCR: Dr. Lee, not only
for myself, but on the part of the readers of the Baylor
University Medical Center Proceedings, I thank
you enormously for pouring your soul out so freely to us.
RVL: Thank you. You were very kind to ask.
RVL's Best
Peer-Reviewed Publications Selected by RVL
7. Lee RV, Buker RS Jr. Congenital
heart disease among the Hutterite brethren. N Engl
J Med 1969;280:1061-1062.
10. Lee RV, Thornton GF, Conn HD.
Liver disease associated with secondary syphilis. N
Engl J Med 1971;284:1423-1425.
13. Lee RV. Cardiopulmonary
resuscitation in the eighteenth century. A historical
perspective on present practice. J Hist Med Allied
Sci 1972;27:418-433.
15. Converse TA, Buker RS Jr, Lee
RV. Hutterite midwifery. Am J Obstet Gynecol
1973;116:719-725.
29. Lee RV, Black FL, Hierholzer WJ
Jr, West BL. A novel pattern of treponemal antibody
distribution in isolated South American Indian
populations. Am J Epidemiol 1978;107:46-53.
43. Lee RV. Scurvy: a contemporary
historical perspective (in three parts). Conn Med
1983;47:629-632, 703-704, Conn Med
1984;48:33-35.
44. Lee RV. Bacon's syndrome. The
decline of natural history in medicine. Am J Med
1984;77:972-976.
47. Lee RV. It's better to be
smart than dumb, or the clinical importance of
ignorance. Am J Med 1985;79:548-551.
49. Lee RV, Rodgers BD, Young C,
Eddy E, Cardinal J. Total parenteral nutrition during
pregnancy. Obstet Gynecol 1986;68:563-571.
52. Lee RV, Rodgers BD, White LM,
Harvey RC. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation of pregnant
women. Am J Med 1986;81:311-318.
55. Lee RV, D'Alauro F, White LM,
Cardinal J. Southeast Asian folklore about pregnancy
and parturition. Obstet Gynecol
1988;71:643-646.
58. Lee RV, Prowten AW, Anthone S,
Satchidanand SK, Fisher JE, Anthone R. Typhlitis due
to Balantidium coli in captive lowland
gorillas. Rev Infect Dis 1990;12:1052-1059.
63. Lee RV, Lippes HA, DiMaggio LA.
Common discomforts (the aches and pains)
complicating normal pregnancy. J Soc Obstet
Gynecol Canada 1992;
14:19-37.
65. Lee RV, Tan Hai Ying, Cheng
Ying Wei, Zhu Fu Fan, Zhang Zhi-Sheng. Medically high
risk pregnancy in China: experience at a provincial
teaching hospital. J Obstet Gynaecol
1993;13:153-162.
66. Lee RV. Is good health good? Pharos
1994;57:35-39.
69. DiMaggio LA, Rubino SE, Lee RV.
Good Samaritans or reticent bystanders? J Travel
Med 1994;1:143-146.
73. Lee RV. Changing times:
reflections on a professional lifetime: an interview
with Paul Beeson. Ann Intern Med
2000;132:71-79.
74. Lee RV. Doctoring to the music
of time. Ann Intern Med 2000;132:11-17.
Essays
Lee RV. The Generalist: A
Jaundiced View/The Jaundiced View/The Jaundiced Eye
1. The specialist veneer. The index
medicus. Health care delivery complaints. Housestaff
training: spectator sport? Am J Med
1982;72:184-187.
2. History in medicine. Am J Med
1982;72:384.
3. Playing doctor. Expertise. Wolf
Point. If you're so good, why ain't you rich? Why
wai. Am J Med 1982;72:554-558.
4. Doctor Pangloss lives!
Generalities. Am J Med 1982;72:717-718.
5. The bedpan gap. Am J Med
1982;73:465-466.
6. Touch. Am J Med
1982;73:617-618.
7. Husbandry.* Am J Med
1982;73:781-782.
8. Why don't painted Indians get
insect bites? Or, the clinical importance of noticing
nonmedical things. Am J Med 1983;74:359-360.
9. Contemporary medical ethics:
sour grapes? Irritability. Am J Med
1983;74:532-534.
10. Lessons from lambing. Why on
earth do you do these silly things? A reply from
Thailand: the girl from Khao I Dang. The only Farang
on the bus. Oriental splendor. Dancing. Am J Med
1983;74:731-736.
11. Role models. Am J Med
1983;75:7-8.
12. The doctor's bag. Am J Med
1983;75:179-180.
13. The art of medicine. Am J
Med 1983;75:381.
14. The country fair. Bullies. Am
J Med 1983;75:731-735.
15. A message from Mister William
Blake. Medicine and maps. Am J Med
1983;75:902-905.
16. Even the small stones count. Am
J Med 1984;76:173-174.
17. Traveling tight. Am J Med
1984;76:349-350.
18. Hot springs. Am J Med
1984;76:562-563.
19. Elegance.* Am J Med
1984;76:770-771.
20. Islands. Am J Med
1984;76:961-962.
21. Kids and tribes. Am J Med
1984;77:5-6.
22. Burnt offerings. Am J Med
1984;77:197-198.
23. Doctors are human too. Am J
Med 1984;77:397-398.
24. Stools. Am J Med
1984;77:777-778.
25. Malpractice malaise. Am J
Med 1986;80:159-160.
26. Winter solstice. Am J Med
1986;80:343-344.
27. Dirt. Am J Med
1986;80:549-552.
28. Sex may be hazardous to your
health. Oncorynchus. Feet. Am J Med
1986;80:764-769.
29. Riding the fences. Am J Med
1987;82:298-301.
30. Generalism in general. Am J
Med 1995;98:304-306.
Lee RV. Second Thoughts
1. Seed catalogs. J Chronic Dis
1985;38:1027-1028.
2. The tyrant of the garden. J
Chronic Dis 1986;39:321-322.
3. Autumn leaves. J Chronic Dis
1986;39:761-762.
4. Midwinter thaw: parsnips and
people. J Chronic Dis 1987;40:179-181.
5. Spring color. J Chronic Dis
1987;40:357-359.
6. Olfaction--and the smell of
summer. J Chronic Dis 1987;40:819-821.
7. Kanji. J Chronic Dis
1987;40:1059-1062.
8. The sensual physician. J Clin
Epidemiol 1988;41:97-99.
9. Too bad toubab; or, doing good
in Mali. J Clin Epidemiol 1988;41:607-610.
10. Medical image. J Clin
Epidemiol 1988;41:699-704.
11. On hunting. J Clin Epidemiol
1988;41:1135-1138.
12. A modest proposal for
preventing elder folk from being a burden to their
children or country, and making them beneficial to
the public. J Clin Epidemiol 1989;42:593-595.
13. Cruel cacophony, boisterous
beeper. J Clin Epidemiol 1990;43:311-312.
14. Tails, tetanus and Turner. J
Clin Epidemiol 1990;43:405-411.
15. The clinical picture.* J
Clin Epidemiol 1990;43:527-531.
16. Eros and Asklepios: thoughts
provoked by an Indian sculpture. J Clin Epidemiol
1990;43:717-721.
17 Computer on the mountain:
technology in remote areas of the developing world. J
Clin Epidemiol 1990;43:841-843.
18. Taking things apart and the art
of arrangement. J Clin Epidemiol
1991;44:1115-1118.
19. Abstract expression. J Clin
Epidemiol 1992;45:803-806.
20. China vignettes: medical
homilies from a visiting professor's journal. J
Clin Epidemiol 1993;46:193-197.
21. An autumn reverie: leaves,
trees, books and libraries. J Clin Epidemiol
1995;48:1285-1287.
22. Fragile environment: cities and
crude oil. J Clin Epidemiol 1995;48:1179-1181.
23. Cambodia journal: 1995. J
Clin Epidemiol 1996;49:937-938.
24. Delaying decay: mummies and
smoked salmon. J Clin Epidemiol 2000;53:217.
Lee RV. Travelling Doctors
1. The start of a voyage: sea salt
and powders. Travel Med Intl 1993;11:24-27.
2. American medicine's
wounded hero of Arctic exploration:
Elisha Kent Kane. Travel Med Intl
1993;11:41-48.
3. Medical voyagers from Haslar
Hospital: medicine as natural history. Travel Med
Intl 1993;11:32-39.
4. Mungo Park: doctor, explorer,
naturalist and anthropologist. Travel Med Intl
1994;12:34-38.
Books and single-issue journals
3. Lee RV (ed in chief), Barron WM,
Cotton D, Coustan D (co-eds). Current Obstetric
Medicine, vol. 1. Chicago: Mosby-Year Book, 1991.
4. Lee RV (ed in chief), Barron WM,
Cotton D, Coustan D (co-eds). Current Obstetric
Medicine, vol. 2. Chicago: Mosby-Year Book, 1993.
5. Lee RV, Garner PA (eds in
chief), Barron WM, Cotton D, Coustan D (co-eds). Current
Obstetric Medicine, vol. 3. Chicago: Mosby-Year
Book, 1995.
6. Lee RV, Garner PA (eds in
chief), Barron WM, Cotton D, Coustan D (co-eds). Current
Obstetric Medicine, vol. 4. Chicago: Mosby-Year
Book, 1996.
9. Lee RV (senior ed), Barbour L,
Garner P, Keely E, Rosene-Montella K (co-eds). Medical
Care of the Pregnant Patient. Philadelphia:
American College of Physicians, 2000. In press.
*Reprinted in The Buffalo
Physician.
|