n December 1984, Dr. Michael A. E.
Ramsay was summoned to the boardroom of Baylor University
MedicalCenter (BUMC) to meet with Mr. Boone Powell, Jr.,
president of the medical center; Dr. John S. Fordtran,
chief of the Department of Internal Medicine; Dr. Gran
B. Klintmalm, recently appointed director of
transplantation services; and other medical staff
leaders. Those already assembled were on a conference
call with Dr. Thomas E. Starzl, professor of surgery and
director of transplantation at the University of
Pittsburgh School of Medicine. First Lady Nancy Reagan
had asked Dr. Starzl if a 4-year-old child, who had been
part of the White House Christmas treelighting
ceremony, could have a liver transplant. An organ was
available, but there were no open hospital beds at
Pittsburgh. Dr. Starzl had called to inquire whether the
transplant could be done as the first liver transplant
procedure at BUMC. The decision was made to proceed. Dr.
Starzl flew to Dallas and together with his previous
fellow, Dr. Klintmalm, performed the first successful
orthotopic liver transplant in Texas, with Dr. Ramsay,
Dr. Peter T. Walling, and Dr. Thomas W. Swygert assisting
with anesthesia.
Organ
transplantation could not have been contemplated save for
centuries of effort to develop effective anesthetic
agents and techniques for managing high-acuity patients
for extended periods of time. Making the momentous
decision to perform the transplant at BUMC was feasible
only because of the near-centurylong effort to
develop BUMC's medical staff, technical support,
equipment, facilities, and financing, together with
detailed planning, guided by Dr. Starzl, to develop a
major organ transplantation program at BUMC.
THE DEVELOPMENT OF
ANESTHESIA
The earliest mention of
anesthesia is found in the Book of Genesis (see above).
Physicians have tried to relieve the pain of surgery
since antiquity:
Opium and
alcohol had long been used as analgesics, and
Dioscorides, who lived at the beginning of the Christian
era, urged that the root of Atrop Mandragora (mandrake)
steeped in wine be given to patients before facing the
knife. Medieval patients were given a soporific
sponge, soaked in opium, mandragora and
hyoscalmine (popularly known as henbane), the poor
man's opium (1).
In 1657 Sir Christopher
Wren (16321723, Figure
1), the
architect of St. Paul's Cathedral, injected opium into a
dog's vein through a quill. Experience taught the
dangers of dulling pains by plying patients with opium,
and few further developments followed until the chemical
revolution produced the first anesthetic gas. In 1766
Antonio Mesmer evolved the technique of
Mesmerism, the first description of hypnotism
as a form of anesthesia. In 1820 a young English surgeon,
Henry Hill Hickman (18001830), vainly endeavored to
get the medical profession to investigate the possibility
of preventing pain during surgical operations. He
experimented on animals, rendering them unconscious by
removing atmospheric air. This resulted in the
understanding of the importance of oxygen and carbon
dioxide in respiration.
Over the centuries, opium
was a commodity available on the free market. Its
chemically produced form, morphia, was introduced in the
1820s, and the hypodermic syringe was introduced in the
1850s and declared the greatest boon given to
medicine since the discovery of chloroform.
Nothing did me any good, Florence Nightingale
noted during one of her illnesses, but a curious
little new fangled operation of putting opium under the
skin, which relieved one for 24 hours (2). In 1898
the German company Bayer introduced heroin
(diacetylmorphine), the heroic drug which,
they said, shared morphine's ability to relieve pain but
was safer.
Prior to October 16,
1846, any surgical operation was accompanied by severe
pain (Figure 2). Preparation for surgery
often included plying patients with alcohol and opium
until they were stuporose. (BUMC representatives found a
similar practice in Romania in 1989 after the fall of the
Ceaucescu regime as they helped rebuild the country's
health care system.) After they were sufficiently groggy
from this premedication technique, patients would be held
down while surgery was rapidly performed. At The London
Hospital, founded in 1775, an operating theatre bell
(cast at the famous Whitechapel foundry) was rung to
summon strong orderlies to restrain patients prior to the
initial incision. Surgeons became very adept at
performing fast operationsamputating a leg in 1 or
2 minutes. Pitilessness was expounded as an
essential characteristic of a surgeon. Pain was
considered a symptom of importance only in differential
diagnosis, not as a problem related to surgical
procedures. (It is fortunate that these conditions and
practices no longer prevailed during the 20th century at
The London Hospital, the alma mater of Dr. Michael
A. E. Ramsay, chief of anesthesiology at BUMC since 1989;
Dr. B. Roy Simpson, chief of anesthesiology from 1975 to
1989; Dr. Adrian E. Flatt, chief of orthopaedics from
1982 to 1996; Dr. Alain Marengo-Rowe, director of special
hematology and transfusion services since 1972; and Dr.
Peter Walling, attending staff anesthesiologist since
1976.) Among The London Hospital's other historical
vignettes are that the Elephant Man's
skeleton is kept in the medical school museum, and Sir
Frederick Treves removed the appendix of the Prince of
Wales (later King Edward VII) in 1902 with anesthesia
administered by Sir Frederick Hewitt. Dr. Hewitt later
designed the first oral airways, probably as a result of
taking care of the king, an overweight, bearded man.
Credit for coining the
word anesthesia (an = without, esthesia =
sensibility) is generally given to Dr. Oliver Wendell
Holmes (18091894).
Nitrous oxide
Joseph Priestley
(17331804) discovered nitrous oxide in 1773, but he
did not realize that it could render a person insensible
to pain. This English Methodist minister also developed
the first carbonated beverage by charging water with
carbon dioxide, but his most important discovery was
oxygen in 1774. Priestley, a supporter of the underclass
in the French Revolution, emigrated to the USA following
a mob attack on his home. He continued his scientific
research in Pennsylvania. Contemporaries there included
Benjamin Franklin (17061790), John Adams
(17351826), Thomas Jefferson (17431826), and
Dr. Benjamin Rush (17451813).
In England, Sir Humphrey
Davy (17781829) carried out further research into
nitrous oxide. Thomas Watt (17341819), the inventor
of the steam engine, designed the first face masks for
delivery of nitrous oxide for Humphrey Davy. In 1800 Davy
published a treatise on nitrous oxide, in which he
observed that it appeared capable of destroying physical
pain.
Nitrous oxide was
demonstrated at stage shows as laughing gas.
During one such show in 1844, a subject fell and injured
his leg. A dentist, Dr. Horace Wells (18151848, Figure
3),
noticed the accident and also observed that the
participant felt no pain. Following this observation,
Wells inhaled nitrous oxide himself while a colleague
painlessly extracted one of his teeth. In January 1845,
he attempted to demonstrate a tooth extraction under
nitrous oxide anesthesia at Massachusetts General
Hospital, but the patient cried out in pain. Dr. Wells
was jeered at as a failure. The crowd laughed at him and
shouted, humbug! Dr. Horace Wells gave up
dentistry, later became a chloroform addict, and then
committed suicide, despondent over his failure.
Ether
The credit for the
initial use of anesthesia for surgical procedures belongs
to Dr. Crawford Long (18151878, Figure
4), a
country practitioner of Jefferson, Jackson County,
Georgia, who had begun using ether for minor surgery
cases on March 30, 1842. His first patient, James
Venable, inhaled from an ether-soaked towel and became
unconscious. Long then removed a cyst from his neck.
However, he did not publish or otherwise publicize
information about his techniques until 1849 (3).
Therefore, the official
recognition for using anesthesia has been given to Dr.
William T. G. Morton (18191868), another dentist
and medical student in Boston, who, on October 16, 1846,
was able to demonstrate successfully the anesthetic
properties of ether at Massachusetts General Hospital (Figure
5).
The patient anesthetized by Dr. Morton underwent without
pain the surgical removal of a jaw tumor by Dr. John C.
Warren (17781856). Dr. Warren announced to the
audience, Gentlemen, this is no humbug!
Warren was fortunate in that Dr. Henry J. Bigelow
published a report of Morton's first 2 successful cases,
thereby giving him the recognition for administering the
first anesthetic for a surgical procedure (4). Dr.
Bigelow wrote: It has long been an important
problem in medical science to devise some method of
mitigating the pain of surgical operations. An efficient
agent for this purpose has at length been
discovered. As news of this development became
known, it was hailed as the greatest gift ever made
to a suffering humanity. This was a uniquely
American discovery; the colonists were finally sending
medical innovation back to the motherlands.
Morton tried to patent
ether as Letheon but was promptly shunned by
his colleagues who considered this very unethical, and
Dr. Warren had him banned from the Commonwealth of
Massachusetts. He withdrew the patent application. The
amphitheater at Massachusetts General Hospital was later
renamed the Etherdome and designated a national historic
site in 1965. The argument still continues on who should
be recognized as the discoverer of anesthesia. The
American College of Surgeons, meeting in Atlanta in 1921,
named Long the discoverer and in 1926 erected a statue of
Long in Statuary Hall, Washington, DC.
The chemical ether was
discovered by Valerius Cordus (15151544), a German
botanist, or perhaps by Paracelsus (c. 14931542),
a Swiss physician. In 1540 Paracelsus sweetened the feed
of fowl with the sweet oil of vitriol (ether) and
discovered that the inhalation of the vapor could induce
sleep in chickens without causing any harm. However, its
potential as an anesthetic was not realized for another
200 years. (There is even some evidence that the
eighth-century Arabian philosopher Jabir Ibn Hayyam had
compounded ether, not realizing its potential as an
anesthetic agent.)
Ether was used by
partygoers to get high. Ether frolic
parties became popular; the pungent gas was
sniffed, frequently causing loss of consciousness. Ether
was also used for respiratory ailments such as asthma and
was one of the early bronchodilators.
Chloroform
An obstetrician from
Edinburgh, Scotland, James Young Simpson (18111870,
Figure 6), was using ether for the
relief of labor pains and delivery. However, he wanted a
more pleasant-smelling compound. His search found
chloroform, which he tried on friends at a dinner party.
Under the influence of this new drug, his wife suddenly
exclaimed, I'm an angel! I'm an angel!
Everyone in the group then quickly became unconscious
under its effects. Therefore, in 1847 Simpson introduced
chloroform into clinical practice. Two years later, on
June 8, 1849, an article appeared in the Texas
Republican entitled Uses of chloroform,
indicating that medical news had traveled to the state.
Later, Sir James Simpson
advocated the use of anesthesia for obstetrics, going
against religious teaching at that time. The Church
regarded the pain of childbirth as a punishment justly
inflicted by God. Simpson defended himself by quoting the
birth of Eve as described in Genesis. However, the battle
was not won until Simpson attended Queen Victoria's birth
of Prince Leopold on April 7, 1853. He asked his friend
and notable anaesthetist, Dr. John Snow, to administer a
chloroform anesthetic to the queen. Snow poured a small
amount of chloroform onto the queen's handkerchief and
held it under her nose. The queen remained conscious but
felt no pain. She became a strong advocate for obstetric
anesthesia, causing a major cultural change that led to
the development of modern obstetrics.
Dr. Snow, later to be
knighted, is recognized as the first anaesthetist (Figure
7). He
was a masterful physician and dedicated researcher. He
made notable advances in anesthesia and was the first to
investigate anesthesia mortality, observing that cardiac
paralysis occurred with increasing concentrations of
chloroform (5). Snow also studied infectious diseases
and, based on his hypothesis that cholera was
water-borne, had water pump handles removed in an area of
London, which led immediately to the cessation of a
cholera epidemic. For this work he is also honored as the
first epidemiologist.
Chloroform was, in fact,
a toxic chemical with lethal effects if given in too high
a concentration. The first reported anesthetic death was
that of Hannah Greener, a 14-year-old child who died of a
chloroform overdose on January 28, 1848. In response to
these risks, Dr. Joseph Clover (18251892, Figure
8)
developed the first apparatus that provided controlled
concentrations of chloroform. This is one of the earliest
reports relating to issues of patient safety.
Because of its toxicity,
chloroform was administered in England only by physicians
who had the scientific knowledge to provide a safe
outcome. Therefore, England employed only physicians for
anesthesia, then and now. Ether anesthesia, unlike
chloroform, was easily mastered and in the USA was
frequently left to the surgeon's nurse or assistant to
administer. This resulted in the development of nurse
anesthesia schools.
Local anesthesia
For centuries, the
Indians in Peru used the saliva produced when chewing
coca leaves to anesthetize wounds. Dr. Sigmund Freud
(18561939) studied the cerebral stimulant effects
of cocaine in 1884, and a surgical intern working with
him, Carl Koller (18571944), tasted the cocaine and
noted that his tongue had become numb. He realized that
cocaine had potential as a topical anesthetic and was
able to anesthetize his own cornea.
In 1888 Dr. Leonard
Corning performed the first spinal block with cocaine,
but it took another 14 years before this technique was
used for surgical operations. Two German physicians, Dr.
Heinrich Quinke and Dr. August Bier, popularized the
technique in Europe, and Dr. Rudolph Matas from New
Orleans wrote extensively about his experience in the
USA. Two French physicians, Dr. Jean Sicard and Dr.
Fernand Cathlin, developed the less dangerous extradural
(epidural) technique in 1901. The general use of cocaine
for nerve blocks was the result of the pioneering work of
Dr. William S. Halsted of Johns Hopkins Hospital, who not
only injected the nerves of thousands of his patients
undergoing minor surgical procedures, but also
experimented on himself. Unfortunately he did not know of
the highly addictive properties of this drug, to which he
developed a lifelong dependency.
Innovations
The development of
anesthesia, initially in the mid-1800s and with major
advances in the last half of the 19th century and
throughout the 20th century, enabled rapid progress in
surgery, obstetrics, organ transplantation, and pain
management.
Concerns for patient
safety led to the development of physiological monitoring
systems. Dr. Harvey Cushing (18691939) introduced
the blood pressure cuff into the operating room. The
electrocardiogram, although designed by Dr. Willem
Einthoven (18601927) in 1903, did not become an
operating room patient monitor until 1945, because of the
risk of explosion. Early cardiac monitors were heavily
shielded and had an oscilloscope that displayed only 3
complexes. These monitors were called bullets
because of their design. They continued as standard
equipment at BUMC until 1978. The continuing expansion
and proliferation of anesthesia-supported surgical and
related procedures required that hospitals add and
increase the size of operating rooms, provide technical
staff to operate equipment, and consider adding
increasingly specialized medical staff members.
In 1924 anesthesia
equipment was still very basic. The British Oxygen
Company in London, Draeger in Germany, and 3 different US
companiesForegger, Heidbrink, and
McKessonwere developing anesthesia delivery
machines. This was a time for innovation and invention.
In 1919 Sir Ivan Magill developed a technique of placing
a breathing tube into the trachea, and endotracheal
anesthesia was born. Later, in 1932, Dr. Ralph Waters, at
the University of Wisconsin in Madison, accidentally
placed a longer endotracheal tube into the right mainstem
bronchus. He realized that he could ventilate one lung
while the surgeon operated on the other lung. Modern
thoracic surgery was now possible.
At the Mayo Clinic in
1934, Dr. John Lundy introduced an intravenous
anesthetic, sodium pentothal, into anesthetic practice.
Pentothal rapidly became the standard induction agent,
being much more pleasant than inhaling the pungent ether.
(It was not until the 1990s that propofol, a more rapidly
metabolized agent with fewer side effects, finally
replaced pentothal.) Although the existence of curare had
been known for many years (it was mentioned by Sir Walter
Raleigh in 1596 as an arrow poison of the South American
Indians), it was not used in surgery to deliberately
cause muscle relaxation to facilitate access to the
abdomen until Dr. Harold Griffith and Dr. Enid Johnson
administered it on January 23, 1942, in Montreal, Canada.
As the medical specialty
of anesthesia grew in importance, the first society was
founded by G. A. F. Erdmann in 1905, The Long Island
Society of Anaesthetists. This became the New York
Society of Anaesthetists in 1911 and became national in
1936 as the American Society of Anaesthetists. In 1945
the title was changed to the American Society of
Anesthesiologists. The American Board of Anesthesiology
was formed in 1937 as an associate of the American Board
of Surgery.
Development of
anesthesia in Texas
The first anesthetic
given in Texas was recorded in May 1850. The 60-year-old
patient, J. Witherspoon, was given chloroform for a
mid-thigh amputation of his gangrenous leg. Dr. J. J. B.
Wright, US Army, administered the anesthetic, and Dr.
George Cupples (18151895) performed the surgery
(6). The first anesthetist in Dallas was Dr. Rufus Whitis
(18591949), and he was referred to as the
physician in charge of chloroform. Dr. Whitis
trained at Jefferson Medical College and came to Dallas
in 1885. He is buried in Oak Cliff Cemetery.
In the 1890s as many as
one third of the physicians practicing in Dallas had
served in the Confederate army or navy. They would have
brought their wartime experience of anesthesia to Dallas
with them. Chloroform anesthesia was extensively used
during the 4 years of the war. Despite its known
toxicity, few deaths were attributed to chloroform, even
though it was estimated to have been used in over 80,000
patients (7, 8).
In 1892 the University of
Texas opened its Medical Branch in Galveston, and Dr.
David Cerna (18571953) joined the Department of
Therapeutics as one of 8 professors on staff. During his
time there he authored numerous articles, among them
studies on opium, belladonna, nitrous oxide, and
chloroform (9, 10). He was able to confirm John Snow's
observations on chloroform but also noted that
respiratory failure preceded cardiac paralysis. Dr. Cerna
was born in Coahuila, Mexico, and had an intense interest
in the culture of the native Indians of that country. In
1932 he wrote an essay on the pharmacology of the ancient
Mexicans, in which he described the use of opium,
obtained from the poppy, being used to narcotize
prisoners to prepare them for human sacrifice, where the
chest was opened and the beating heart offered up to the
gods (11).
The Texas Society of
Medical Anaesthetists was organized in 1939, with Dr.
Carl Hoeflich as president. In 1948 the name was changed
to the Texas Society of Anesthesiologists, with Dr. J. G.
Youngblood as president. Dr. Joe Billy Wood and Dr.
Pepper Jenkins played a significant role in this
development.
THE TEXAS BAPTIST
MEMORIAL SANITARIUM: 19031921
The Texas Baptist
Memorial Sanitarium (TBMS), the progenitor of today's
BUMC, was established in 1903, a period dominated by the
triumvirate of anesthesia, asepsis, and surgical
pathological anatomy and characterized by resection to
cure tumors, inflammations, injuries, or anomalies. The
first hospital structure was a residence converted for
use as a clinic and private hospital by Dr. Charles M.
Rosser (18611945). Soon found inadequate for
patient care and teaching, it was closed and replaced by
a community hospital with operating rooms, patient rooms,
and wardsa total of 250 beds in 6 large wards and
114 private rooms. The new hospital opened in October
1909. Shortly thereafter, Dr. Edward H. Cary, one of the
nation's outstanding eye, ear, nose, and throat surgeons,
performed the first surgical procedure in the
amphitheater and planned it so that spectators, including
family members of the patient, could watch the operation
(12). Dr. Elbert Dunlap and Dr. G. Hackler performed the
first laparotomy, and an intern, Dr. Abell D. Hardin,
gave the anesthetic. From 1909 until 1919, most of the
anesthetics were administered by interns. A few surgeons
had medical doctors or dentists give their anesthetics.
In 1915 Dr. John R. Worley and Dr. James Granger Poe came
to TBMS to administer anesthesia.
In the early years of
TBMS, surgery was performed under ether, chloroform, or
nitrous oxide anesthesia. Dr. John Worley was the first
person to administer nitrous oxide at TBMS. He had
extensive experience in the use of nitrous oxide in
obstetric anesthesia (13). His office was located in the
Medical Arts building downtown, and he always carried a
little black bag and wore a black coat. In his obituary
printed in 1953, he was described as a urologist,
dermatologist, and anaesthetist.
Ether and chloroform were
delivered by the open drop technique: a rag was soaked in
the anesthetic liquid and held over the patient's face by
a wire Schimmelbusch face mask. The rag was kept soggy by
the addition of more anesthetic dropped onto it from a
bottle. The technique was taught until the 1970s; being
portable, it could be used in the field. It was also very
inexpensive and could be used in countries where the cost
of more modern anesthetics was prohibitive. The use of
ether finally stopped at BUMC in the 1970s as halothane
became the agent of choice. Flammable anesthetics were
then banned because of the risk of explosion from static
electricity or electrical cautery used in the close
vicinity.
James Granger Poe, MD
From 1915 until 1919, Dr.
James Granger Poe (18731935, Figure
9)
gave anesthesia for Dr. A. B. Small. In 1919 he decided
to limit his practice solely to anesthesia and became the
first physician to be employed by the hospital as an
anesthesiologist. Putting patients to sleep with open
drop ether, he would say, Think about peaches and
cream, think about peaches and cream, until one
young lady of the street told him in no uncertain terms
what to do with that!
Dr. Poe was born in
Alvaton, Kentucky, on April 3, 1873. He graduated from
the Southern Normal School and Business College at
Bowling Green, Kentucky, in 1889. By special dispensation
from the dean of the University of Tennessee Medical
School, he was allowed to graduate with first honors in
his class of 91 students before he was 21 years old. He
began practicing and teaching medicine in Dallas in 1898.
He published the first anesthetic textbook in Texas, Modern
General Anaesthesia, in 1926 (Figure
10)
(14). Inside the front cover of the book, he wrote,
To the service of those who suffer and need help in
the ministry of surgery this little volume is
dedicated. A second edition was published in 1931.
He also wrote a second textbook devoted to his experience
with chloroform anesthesia.
In 1920 Dr. Poe, together
with a nurse anesthetist, Mr. L. A. (Pinkie) Sanders
developed the Sanders anesthetic machine. The Sanders
machine was a 4-prong apparatus with 2 tanks of nitrous
oxide, 1 tank of carbon dioxide, and 1 tank of oxygen (Figure
11).
Dr. Poe believed that this was a very safe machine in
regards to any risk of explosion:
The
Sanders Apparatus, which embodies the most practical
construction for the administration of Ethylene-oxygen,
Nitrous Oxide-oxygen, Carbon dioxide, and Ether combined
as desired, by the Gatch rebreathing method, was devised
in our own service by L. A. Sanders and is used
exclusively in the hospital, and is also extensively used
throughout Texas, and in other states, with a tabulation
of approximately 185,000 administrations of Ethylene
without an explosion occurring. Therefore we believe that
the safety and proficiency of this machine and method is
thoroughly established, and we feel as confident in the
use of Ethylene as we do Ether in anesthesia (15).
However, the gas flow was
completely unregulated, and the mixture delivered was
often highly toxic. Nevertheless, the Sanders machine was
very popular for 20 years.
Dr. Poe died at age 62
years in his home at 4110 Junius Street.
BAYLOR HOSPITAL and
BAYLOR UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL: 19211950
In early 1921, TBMS
became part of Baylor University and was renamed Baylor
Hospital (BH). It was the principal teaching hospital of
Baylor College of Medicine until the school moved to
Houston in 1943. The hospital was renamed Baylor
University Hospital (BUH) in 1936.
During the 1920s through
the 1950s, advances in surgery were, of necessity, often
preceded by advances in anesthesiology.
Nurse anesthesia
Shortly after TBMS became
BH, Dr. Poe became the first medical director of the
Department of Anesthesia, which at that time included 3
nurse anesthetists. Mrs. L. C. Hart, hired in 1919, was
the first nurse anesthetist. In 1922 Dr. Poe established
a nurse anesthetist training program within BH, later to
be called the Baylor School of Nurse Anesthetists. The
first student nurse was Mrs. Eunice Oliver, who entered
on October 1, 1922, and completed her course in 4 months.
The next student was Miss Bess Huskerson (Duncan) in
1923, and she was followed by Mrs. Velma Goode Thompson
Ferguson in 1924.
Mrs. Velma Ferguson
graduated in February 1925 and became a Baylor
anesthetist. The next year, 1926, she was appointed
assistant director of nurse anesthesia, and in 1930 she
became director of the School of Nurse Anesthetists, a
position she held until 1963. At that time, Mrs.
Ferguson's 42-year tenure was the longest for any Baylor
employee. A Bell County rattlesnake played a leading role
in the start of her career. The rattler's bite almost
killed her younger brother but for Velma's quick and
daring treatment. An admiring doctor convinced her mother
that the girl should be allowed to study nursing.
When she became director
of the School of Nurse Anesthetists, she was joined by
Mrs. Sallie Knight Moore, a graduate of Parkland
Hospital. Together they developed a very successful nurse
anesthesia program. In the early days of their careers,
they had to purchase rubber tubing and fashion their own
intratracheal tubes to help patients breathe in certain
operations.
In 1963 the School of
Nurse Anesthetists was flourishing. Mrs. Lucille
Stampley, a graduate of the school in 1951, became the
director, and Miss Bennie Sinclair became the assistant
director. Between 1929 and 1970, a significant number of
anesthetics were administered by nurse anesthetists (Figure
12).
The school continued to do well until 1978. At that time
the recruitment of anesthesiologists had resulted in an
insufficient variety of cases available for the school to
maintain accreditation, and the school was closed. The
school had existed for 56 years, and when it closed it
was fully accredited by the American Association of Nurse
Anesthetists and in good standing. Approximately 400
graduates had passed through.
Department leadership
Dr. Howard Dupuy took
over direction of the anesthesia department in 1935. He
continued the practice of supervising nurse anesthetists.
Ten years later, in 1944, Dr. Dupuy left to return to the
practice of orthopaedics at the Dallas Medical and
Surgical Clinic. Dr. Earl Foster Weir (The
Moose) was then appointed director of the
department. Dr. Weir was the first physician trained in
anesthesia to practice in Dallas. He took a residency in
Iowa with Dr. Stewart Cullen, a notable figure in
American anesthesia.
With increasing surgical
demands, increasing patient acuity, and the move of the
Baylor School of Medicine to Houston, an anesthesiology
residency program was established at BUH. The first
resident was Dr. Joe Billy Wood, who, upon completion of
his residency in 1948, became Dr. Weir's assistant.
BAYLOR UNIVERSITY
HOSPITAL AND BAYLOR UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER:
19501981
After the Second World
War, especially after 1950, BUH developed progressively
as a medical center and in 1977 was renamed Baylor
University Medical Center. During this period, Mr. Boone
Powell, Sr., served as executive director. The George W.
Truett Memorial Hospital was completed in 1950, the Karl
and Esther Hoblitzelle Memorial Hospital was added in
1959, the Erik and Margaret Jonsson Medical and Surgical
Hospital was finished in 1970, and the Carr P. Collins
Hospital was dedicated in 1972. Specialized facilities
included the Charles A. Sammons Cancer Center, A. Webb
Roberts Center for Continuing Education, Caruth Surgical
Research Laboratory, and the 2-towered Baylor Medical
Plaza physicians' office building.
As BUH, a typical
community hospital of its era, was transformed into a
major medical center and a regional referral center
offering progressively more sophisticated services, it
developed a larger medical staff comprising
board-certified specialists in most recognized fields,
attracted referral patients from northeast Texas,
expanded residency programs, and encouraged clinical
research.
This was the time when
the need for new technology grew, as did biochemical and
immunological knowledge. The increasingly systemic
approach taken for diagnostics, treatment, and risk and
outcome assessment often blurred the traditional
frontiers between surgery, anesthesia, and other
disciplines, medical and beyond. This was also the era in
which surgery was replaced by other therapies based on a
metabolic understanding of disease. Moreover, novel
procedures such as prosthetic joint replacement and
open-heart surgery were replacing traditional surgical
and anesthesia techniques. These changes called for the
major development of BUH's cadre of anesthesiologists and
anesthesia services.
Introduction of
private practice
As BUH's medical staff
was expanded, Dr. Joe Billy Wood and Dr. Gerald G.
Mullikin (Figure 13), both graduates of Dr.
Weir's program, were granted staff privileges for the
private practice of anesthesiology in 1950. This was
against the wishes of Dr. Weir and required much
fortitude and persistence on their part. In 1952 Dr.
Louis Porter (Figure
13), another
graduate of Dr. Weir's program, joined Dr. Wood's
practice. Dr. Porter was followed by Dr. George Emmett,
the next graduate of the program.
These early private
practitioners went on to receive other honors. Dr. Wood
became chief of the department in 1964, and Dr. Emmett
became interim chief in 1974. Dr. Joe Billy Wood was
elected president of the Texas Society of
Anesthesiologists in 1955. Dr. Gerald Mullikin was
elected president of the Texas Society of
Anesthesiologists in 1969, and in 1982 Dr. Louis Porter
became the first anesthesiologist to be elected president
of BUMC's medical staff. The ultimate accolade was
awarded to Dr. Oliver F. Mike Bush, another
of the private practitioners (who practiced mainly at St.
Paul Hospital); he was elected president of the American
Society of Anesthesiologists in 1964.
Raymond F. Courtin, MD
In July 1954 Dr. Weir
retired and returned to Wisconsin. Dr. Raymond F.
Courtin, an English physician, was recruited from the
Mayo Clinic and appointed chief of anesthesia (Figure
14).
Dr. Courtin had studied under 2 great pioneers of
anesthesia, Dr. John Lundy and Dr. Albert Faulconer at
the Mayo Clinic. Dr. Courtin was awarded a master's of
science degree in anesthesiology from the University of
Minnesota for his thesis entitled
Electroencephalography during surgical anesthesia
with nitrous oxide and ether (16). He was the first
person to describe the effects of an anesthetic agent on
the electroencephalograph and how it could be used to
accurately assess the depth of anesthesia. He brought
this important experience to BUH and presented the
results of his continued research into the effects of
halothane on the electroencephalogram at the World
Congress of Anesthesiologists in London, England, in 1968
(17). This work proved to be ahead of its time, and only
in recent years has such a monitor become commonplace in
anesthetic practice as a tool to prevent awareness under
anesthesia.
Dr. Courtin promoted
regional anesthesia very strongly and brought his
capability and enthusiasm to BUH, expounding the virtues
of regional anesthesia and using it almost exclusively.
The timing was good, as drugs such as lidocaine, first
used as a local anesthetic by Dr. T. Gordh in Stockholm,
Sweden, were now readily available. Dr. Courtin
introduced caudal and epidural anesthesia to BUH.
The first pain clinics in
the Dallas area were started by Dr. Courtin. He tried to
persuade the medical staff and the administration about
the virtues of a pain clinic in 1956 but was opposed.
Despite persistent efforts he was unable to create a pain
clinic at Baylor, so in 1976 he opened his own clinic on
Junius Street, next door to BUH. He was joined by Miss
Jean Simo, CRNA, who later became Mrs. Courtin.
Courtin had worked with
Dr. John Lloyd of Oxford when the latter developed the
cryoprobe. The cryoprobe is an instrument and technique
used for freezing nerves of spinal cord lesions without
causing permanent damage. This technique also proved to
be very useful in the treatment of acute facet joint pain
(18). In addition to his accomplishments with regional
techniques, Dr. Courtin introduced a new inhalational
agent, halothane, to BUMC. This agent initially was
administered in a similar way to trichlorethylene because
its effect on soda lime was unknown. Halothane maintained
its foremost place in clinical practice until the late
1990s, when it was finally replaced by sevoflurane, a
minimally metabolized agent that patients recovered from
quickly.
Dr. Courtin resigned as
chief in 1966, and Dr. J. B. Wood was appointed in his
place.
Postanesthesia care
unit
In 1956 the Parkland
Hospital experience showed that patients could come to
harm after surgical procedures were completed and they
had been returned to their rooms. The anesthetic agents
required metabolism for recovery to take place, and this
took many hours when the patient was still obtunded and
potentially compromised. Therefore, at BUH, 5 nurses were
designated recovery nurses. Each nurse under
the direction of Miss Joyce Mackie, RN, would accompany
patients from the operating room to their hospital room.
The nurses had portable suction machines, as well as
various airways and blood pressure equipment.
It was not until 1962, 6
years later, that a dedicated recovery room was opened on
the fifth floor of the Truett Hospital building close to
the operating rooms. Now called the postanesthesia care
unit (PACU), under the management of Ms. Jean Aguanno,
RN, this area acts as an overflow intensive
care ward as well as a recovery unit.
Development of the
anesthesiology staff
Joe Billy Wood, MD. Dr.
Wood was the first anesthesiologist to enter the private
practice of anesthesiology in Dallas (Figure
15).
He became chief of anesthesia in 1966 and was
instrumental in establishing an open medical staff,
within which competitive, consultative anesthesia
practice was developed. Dr. Wood also created an advisory
committee to help establish and implement departmental
policies and procedures. The advisory committee continues
as an integral and important component of departmental
activities at BUMC.
On November 30, 1982, Dr.
Wood was awarded the Dallas County Anesthesiology Society
Citation of Merit. This was given in recognition of
his many years of dedicated service to patients through
the practice of anesthesiology; in appreciation of his
having opened the frontiers for the private practice of
anesthesiology in Dallas; in gratitude for his steadfast
espousal of the highest principles of ethics in
anesthesiology; and in thankfulness for his part in
providing a bright heritage for those following in
anesthesiology. Dr. Wood resigned as chief in 1975,
and Dr. George Emmett took over as interim chief.
Harold Boehning, MD. In
1958 Dr. Harold Boehning (Figure
16)
joined the attending staff, after surmounting the
restriction that limited the total number of
anesthesiologists at BUH to 10. How this restriction came
to be is a controversial issue. According to some
anesthesiologists on the staff at the time, the hospital
administration wanted to protect the nurse anesthesia
program. Other anesthesiologists believed some of the
existing department members wanted to protect their
private practices. Whatever the reason, the staff opened
up from that point forward, with the only restrictions
being related to the quality of the applicant.
Dr. Boehning had an
outstanding career in which he promoted most strongly the
private consultative practice of anesthesiology. He was a
supporter, both politically and clinically, of anesthesia
as the practice of medicine. Dr. Boehning, along with Dr.
Oneita Hedgecock, developed a large group of
anesthesiologists who practiced mainly at Baylor. He was
elected president of the Texas Society of
Anesthesiologists in 1978 and later the Dallas County
Medical Society. For his major contributions to the
Dallas County Medical Society, he was awarded the Max
Cole Leadership Award in 1995. Dr. Boehning chaired the
advisory committee for most of Dr. Simpson's tenure as
chief.
Donovan Campbell, MD. In
1959 Dr. Donovan Campbell (Figure
16)
joined the BUH staff, having previously been chief of
anesthesia at March Air Force Base in Riverside,
California. Dr. Campbell believed that the Baylor
anesthesia department should be the best in the world. He
personally obtained state-of-the-art physiological
monitors so that patients undergoing open-heart surgery
could be monitored intensively. This pioneered the
concept of intensive monitoring of the cardiovascular
system for all high-acuity patients.
Dr. Campbell stayed on
the cutting edge of anesthesia, bringing new
techniques and technology to Baylor. He introduced
halothane into neurosurgery and personally purchased a
calibrated halothane vaporizer that opened its use for
thoracic anesthesia. To reduce the cost of halothane, he
developed a semi-closed patient rebreathing system to
conserve the use of the agent. Dr. Campbell was very
independent and was prepared to go against the tide of
medical opinion if he believed that he was right, and
frequently he was. He developed the technique of brachial
artery cannulation for monitoring blood pressure
continuously. Even without sound evidence, many
authorities adamantly described this as dangerous. After
using this technique on many thousands of patients, Dr.
Campbell was able to show how safe the procedure really
was. Now it has been shown to be a better monitoring
technique for patients with poor cardiac ventricular
function than the more traditional radial artery
cannulation. Dr. Campbell's interest in thoracic
anesthesia led him to bring the double-lumen
endobronchial tube for differential lung ventilation to
Baylor. Dr. Campbell was an ardent supporter of proper
patient care, and to the chagrin of many, he would not
tolerate poor care or compromise his high principles.
Oneita Hedgecock, MD. The
first female anesthesiologist to join the Baylor medical
staff was Dr. Oneita Hedgecock in 1961 (Figure
16).
She was appointed following completion of her residency
in Los Angeles. The first female anesthesiologist in
Texas had been Dr. Claudia Potter, who practiced in
Temple, Texas, from 1902 until 1948, but she had not
completed a residency training program. The first female
anesthesiology resident graduated at the University of
Iowa in 1923. Therefore it was well overdue for this
appointment to be made at Baylor.
Dr. Hedgecock was an
ardent patient advocate. She introduced patient warming
blankets to maintain body temperature during prolonged
surgeries. She also chaired the morbidity and mortality
conferences and a continuous quality improvement
committee. She became a founding member of the
credentialing committee at Baylor, probably one of the
most influential committees at that time.
Other physicians. The
attending staff was gradually increased when Dr. Frank H.
Coufal, Jr., and Dr. Maurice W. Epstein joined the staff
in 1960 and 1961, respectively, after completing
residency programs at The University of Texas
Southwestern Medical School.
Dr. Epstein had trained
in the technique of controlled hypotension and was able
to introduce this to Baylor, enabling oral surgery
procedures to be undertaken with a much reduced blood
loss. The technique that he used included the agent
trichloroethylene, which had a residual analgesic effect
that improved the recovery of these patients. Dr. Epstein
also pioneered the use of roller boards so
that patients could be safely transferred from gurneys to
the operating room table and back without injury to
either the patients or the care team.
Obstetric anesthesia
(part 1)
The lack of the
formalized provision of anesthesia care for obstetrical
patients was recognized as a major factor in the
significant national incidence of maternal morbidity.
Therefore, in 1971 Dr. Robert Rehmet (Figure
16),
having completed a residency at the University of
Washington under Dr. John Bonica, joined the staff and
developed an obstetrical anesthesia service. This was the
first of several initiatives to provide first-class
anesthesia for obstetric patients and the first
specialized obstetric anesthesia service in Dallas.
Despite strong support from some members of the obstetric
division, many of the obstetricians continued to provide
anesthesia themselves for their patients or supervised
the nurse anesthetists.
Dr. Rehmet was not
allowed to develop an obstetric care team with the nurse
anesthetists because of anesthesia department policies;
therefore, he had to work singlehandedly, only able to
look after one patient at a time. This severely limited
his role in the labor and delivery unit, and after 18
months with little support, he abandoned his attempts and
decided to devote his efforts to surgical anesthesia.
B. Roy Simpson, MD
In 1972 Dr. Campbell made
one of many visits to The London Hospital in England. He
made rounds in the anesthetic unit under Professor B. Roy
Simpson. This unit was internationally recognized as one
of the best anesthesia programs in the world. Dr.
Campbell developed a firm relationship with Dr. Simpson
and reported to Mr. Boone Powell, Sr., that BUH had an
opportunity to recruit this world-renowned figure to come
to Dallas to head the medical center's Department of
Anesthesiology.
Dr. Simpson accepted the
position as chief of the Department of Anesthesiology at
BUH in 1975 and moved to Dallas (Figure
17).
His aims were to transform the department, with its
existing talented anesthesiologists engaged in the
private practice of anesthesia, into a strong department
with a more academic background and to improve the image
of the department within BUH. His arrival had a major
impact on the delivery and standard of anesthesia at
Baylor and in the rest of the community. He started
weekly anesthesia grand rounds that continue today. These
meetings included presentations from visiting professors,
morbidity and mortality sessions, and scientific
meetings.
Dr. Simpson brought
state-of-the-art physiological monitoring systems to each
operating room. He also set up the first anesthesia
technician program and provided training for them by a
biomedical engineering department dedicated to the
operating room. As equipment became more complex, the
technician program ensured safety, proper maintenance of
equipment, and an immediate response if failure occurred.
These advances established Baylor's anesthesia department
as a model for the city.
Dr. Roy Simpson was a
dedicated educator. With the assistance of Dr. Ralph R.
Tompsett, the director of Baylor's medical education
program and chief of internal medicine, he set up an
internship program for aspiring anesthesiologists.
Dr. Simpson took on many
political battles during his tenure, mainly
because of his zeal to develop a first-class anesthesia
department delivering the best possible care to the
patient. He did not seek the easy route of compromise but
took controversies head-on. He realized the significant
amount of revenue brought in by the department and also
the considerable expense involved in keeping it running.
Therefore, he appointed a business manager, Ms. Elaine
Ganter, MBA, to oversee the budget. This provided the
department with sound financial management, and the
department continues to demonstrate a positive revenue
flow.
Dr. Simpson trained in
anesthesia at the world-famous department at the
Radcliffe Infirmary, Oxford. He was a prot?g? of Sir
Robert Macintosh, who invented the curved laryngoscope
blade in 1943. While at Oxford, Dr. Simpson published a
seminal paper on the management of postoperative pain
with a thoracic epidural technique for patients
undergoing upper abdominal surgery who had respiratory
insufficiency (19). This study led to the recognition
that proper pain relief could facilitate recovery from
surgery. In his younger days, Dr. Simpson was a national
sprinter, rugby football player, and cricketer.
Dr. Simpson continued
enhancing his national and international reputation and
that of Baylor by being elected a member of the committee
on panels and the committee on scientific papers of the
American Society of Anesthesiologists. On numerous
occasions he was invited to give presentations as a
visiting professor, including a 4-week lecture tour of
Latin America in 1982. He resigned as chief in 1989 but
continued on active staff at Baylor until 1993.
Obstetric anesthesia
(part 2)
The obstetric anesthesia
problem had not been resolved when Dr.
Simpson joined the staff. He recruited a group of
anesthesiologists, many from the United Kingdom, to have
obstetric anesthesia as one of their major interests.
This team led by Dr. Simpson included Dr. Courtin, Dr.
Peter Walling, Dr. Michael Ramsay, Dr. Colin Blogg, Dr.
Robert Parks, and Dr. Catherine Blakeney. This group,
formed in 1977, provided 24-hour in-house obstetric
anesthesia service. The venture was only a partial
success since many obstetricians continued to provide
their own epidural analgesia for labor but wanted an
anesthesiologist waiting in the wings if a
problem occurred. This made it difficult for the group to
make a living solely from obstetrics. Therefore, they
also provided consultation to the main operating rooms. A
single high standard of obstetric anesthesia was
difficult to introduce, as was the team concept in labor
and delivery. This effort, therefore, did not prevail.
The major hurdles, however, had been addressed and
recognized and the major battles won.
Common sense was about to
prevail and, undaunted, Dr. Simpson, having now made
tremendous advances in the delivery of quality obstetric
anesthesia at Baylor, sought to attract another group of
anesthesiologists with extensive experience in obstetric
anesthesia who would make this the prime focus of their
practice. He was strongly supported by younger
obstetricians such as Dr. Robert Gunby and Dr. Dennis
Factor. The timing was now right, and Dr. Roger Bullard
was recruited to continue the development of a
comprehensive obstetric anesthesia service. An anesthesia
team with nurse anesthetists and anesthesiologists
working together was formed. This model of obstetric
anesthesia service was later adopted by the other major
hospitals in Dallas. Dr. Bullard also developed a
laryngoscope with prisms and lenses, so that it could
facilitate difficult intubations. This instrument has
become popular worldwide.
Peter T. Walling, MD
Dr. Peter Walling (Figure
18)
joined the department in 1976, having spent a year in
South Africa as a visiting professor. He trained at The
London Hospital and joined Dr. Simpson's anesthetic unit,
where as a senior lecturer and consultant he used an
animal experiment model to identify the cause of an
outbreak of neurological complications associated with
spinal anesthesia in Brazil. Although his work prevented
further catastrophes, because of political difficulties
and the threat of legal proceedings, this important work
was never published. Dr. Walling had the distinction of
delivering the last chloroform anesthetic in 1974, albeit
unintentionally, when a halothane vaporizer was charged
with the historic volatile agent.
Dr. Walling's inventive
nature resulted in several innovations. He designed a
safety syringe for pulmonary artery catheters
that would not rupture the flotation balloon (20). In
addition to his several medical inventions, he developed
a transportable whole steer barbecue
apparatus. He toured around the state of Texas providing
first-class barbecue for major events. Unfortunately,
this venture went up in smoke on the road to a large
company gathering!
Law Sone, Jr., MD
Dr. Sone (Figure
18)
joined Dr. Wood and Dr. Porter in practice at BUH in
1963. They were the leaders in developing a group of
anesthesiologists with a reputation of unsurpassed
quality. Dr. Sone became the 44th president of the Texas
Society of Anesthesiologists in 1986 and was assistant
chief of anesthesia at BUMC from 1992 until he retired
from practice in 1998. He chaired the advisory committee
of the department for over 10 years, and his counsel was
sought often by Dr. Simpson and Dr. Ramsay. Dr. Sone was
very influential in the recruitment of Dr. Ramsay from
London. He traveled to England and spent a day in
practice with Dr. Ramsaya crucial factor in his
decision to relocate.
BAYLOR UNIVERSITY
MEDICAL CENTER AND BAYLOR HEALTH CARE SYSTEM:
19811999
In 1981 Baylor Health
Care System was created, and BUMC was separately
incorporated as the core hospital (with hospitals within
it) of what was to become a multihospital, multifaceted,
integrated health care systemone of America's
larger voluntary hospital systems. This major step was
made, with Mr. Boone Powell, Jr., as president, to allow
the health care system to continue to develop and serve
patients in the face of increasing competition and
regulation, the growth of managed care, and the decline
of fee-for-service payment. It also enhanced the system's
access to capital needed to finance new facilities and
advanced diagnostic and treatment equipment.
Same-day surgery
admission
By 1984 the insurance
companies and other payors were starting to exert
pressure to limit the length of hospital stays for
surgical procedures. Admitting patients the night before
surgery was considered unnecessary by payors. They
insisted on admitting patients on the same day as their
surgery, which created problems in obtaining essential
laboratory data, chest radiographs, electrocardiograms,
history and physical examination reports, and previous
records. It also constrained the time available for
preanesthetic assessment. To meet these needs, Dr.
Simpson undertook the organization of a same-day surgery
admission center. Here, appropriate preoperative tests
could be performed. With patients all admitted in the
same area, not far from the operating rooms, the
anesthesiologists had an opportunity to make preoperative
rounds. The further development of this area was
undertaken by Dr. Anthony D. Lehner, who helped improve
communications between physician offices and the center.
Ambulatory
outpatient surgery
At the same time, the
need for a freestanding ambulatory outpatient surgery
center near BUMC was recognized. The concept was that
relatively short procedures could be performed on
otherwise generally fit patients in a cost-effective and
efficient manner. The planning task force stipulated that
the medical director of the ambulatory surgery center
should be an anesthesiologist and that an
anesthesiologist should be assigned to each operating
room for an entire day. The initial choice as medical
director was Dr. Bruce Laubach, who had taken over the
directorship of obstetric anesthesia from Dr. Bullard.
Dr. Laubach was heavily involved in the planning and
construction of the new surgicenter. At the
last minute, however, he decided to join several
obstetricians and build a second competing surgery unit
across the street from BUMC, using the experience he
gained from the Baylor project. At this point Dr. Robert
Rehmet stepped forward and agreed to take the position of
medical director rather than have an outside search for a
candidate who would be unknown to both the surgeons and
anesthesiologists. Dr. Rehmet introduced the concept of
dedicated anesthesia in a proposal to improve
efficiency and provide more economic care in the
surgicenter. This proposal sparked considerable
controversy in the department.
Dedicated anesthesia
The concept of one
operating roomone anesthesiologist, or
so-called dedicated anesthesia, was a radical
change in physician practice at Baylor. This was met with
significant opposition from those physicians in the
department who had fought in the past for, and strongly
believed in, the consultative practice of anesthesia. The
consultative mode of practice meant that a surgeon or
patient could select an anesthesiologist of his or her
choice and not take an assigned physician. Many surgeons
and anesthesiologists felt so strongly about this issue
that they elected not to practice at the ambulatory
outpatient surgery center. The existence of 2 practice
patterns on 1 campus inevitably led to considerable
tension when the 2 systems interacted.
The low-cost,
super-efficient surgicenter became very successful, and
by 1989, most of the dedicated anesthesia was
being provided by one group of anesthesiologists. This
was arranged by Dr. Dennis Johnson, who organized a group
of anesthesiologists known as Metropolitan Anesthesia
Consultants. He reached an agreement with the department
that in exchange for providing 24-hour coverage for
trauma patients, they would get the lion's share of the
SurgiCare practice. This was approved by department
members.
Dr. Rehmet obtained a
master's degree in business administration and became a
leader in the development of ambulatory surgery centers.
He is now the medical director of a joint partnership
between Baylor Health Care System and United Surgical
Partners and oversees an extensive network of ambulatory
surgery centers.
Roberts Hospital
In 1989 the Roberts
Hospital was built as a component of BUMC and included an
operating suite of 26 rooms. The design of these rooms
and the physiological monitoring equipment was in part
the result of a considerable amount of work and expertise
from Dr. William A. Paulsen. Dr. Paulsen was recruited by
Dr. Simpson as a biomedical engineer. He was a unique
individual in that he also had been trained as a
physician assistant in anesthesia. He was a leader in his
field, gaining national stature as a major organizer of
the Association for the Advancement of Medical
Instrumentation. Dr. Paulsen was responsible for
Marquette monitoring equipment being placed throughout
the hospital. This state-of-the-art equipment could be
found not only in the operating rooms but also in the
intensive care units and special procedure rooms. Such
uniformity provided safety, as only 1 system had to be
learned by those using the equipment. Dr. Paulsen also
introduced mass spectrometry to the operating rooms. This
system provided for gas analysis to be performed for each
patient so that proper ventilation could be confirmed and
adequate levels of anesthesia could be monitored.
In the new Roberts
Hospital, to facilitate the anesthesiologists in properly
assessing their patients prior to coming to the operating
room, a preanesthetic assessment area was set up in close
proximity to the operating rooms. Here patients and their
families could be visited by anesthesiologists.
Liver transplants
As described earlier, the
first liver transplant was performed in December 1984 by
Dr. Thomas Starzl and Dr. G?ran Klintmalm, with Drs.
Michael Ramsay, Peter Walling, and Thomas Swygert
providing anesthesia. As the new transplantation service
was established at BUMC, Dr. Simpson asked Dr. Ramsay to
take charge of transplant anesthesia and to organize and
coordinate the anesthesia consultation. This was not an
easy task. Few volunteers could be found, as initially
these procedures took place late at night and were very
strenuous to manage. No single group of anesthesiologists
was prepared to take on the transplants. Therefore,
volunteers from 3 different groups came together to form
a liver team. Fortuitously, this allowed for flexibility
in the provision of anesthesia since the procedures
frequently took place when anesthesiologists were already
committed to busy schedules.
Over the next few months,
the infrastructure of a liver transplant program was put
in place. Dr. Swygert spent a month in Pittsburgh with
Dr. Andre de Wolf, Dr. Starzl's lead anesthesiologist.
Dr. Swygert became medical director of Texas Surgery
Center and assistant chief of the department in 1998 (Figure
18).
Dr. William Paulsen played a significant role in putting
together physiological recording devices so that data
could be retrieved for research purposes. Mr. Guy Prater,
senior perfusionist at Baylor, along with Dr. Paulsen,
developed a veno-venous bypass system to assist venous
return when the patient was anhepatic.
Transplant
anesthesia fellowship
A major-organ transplant
anesthesia fellowship was initiated by Dr. Ramsay, with
Dr. Timothy Valek as the first fellow in July 1985. This
rigorous fellowship eventually expanded into 2 positions
and attracted many later-to-be very successful
anesthesiologists. Many graduates from the program stayed
on as staff members, having demonstrated their experience
in taking care of the sickest patients. The clinical
research performed by these fellows resulted in numerous
publications in major medical journals and presentations
at national and international meetings. Dr. Charles
Whitten, a fellow in 1988, went on to become the Jenkins
Professor at The University of Texas Southwestern Medical
School.
Anesthesia research
Dr. Paulsen not only
contributed enormously to the running of the department,
but he also assisted with research efforts that were
beginning at this time. The liver transplant program was
the stimulus to the development of a very active
anesthesia research program. To date, >100 major
manuscripts have been published in peer-reviewed journals
relating to the transplantation programs and anesthesia.
Some of the significant contributions made by the
department to liver transplantation have included
demonstrating that the processing and reinfusion of
salvaged blood during the procedure was safe and
effective. The physiological changes associated with
veno-venous bypass were described, and several
contributions to the better understanding of renal
function in end-stage liver disease were made. The
management of patients with portopulmonary hypertension
has been elucidated from the program's leading experience
in this field. Research studies completed in the
following areas have resulted in significant recognition
for members of BUMC's medical staff:
- Renal
protection during orthotopic liver
transplantation (21)
- The
safe control of fibrinolysis during liver
transplantation by using low-concentration
infusions of antifibrinolytic agents (22)
- Assessment
of liver graft function intraoperatively by
monitoring the metabolism of neuromuscular
blocking agents (23)
- Evaluation
of the role of inhaled nitric oxide in
portopulmonary hypertension and hepatopulmonary
syndrome (24)
The B. Roy Simpson
Anesthesia Research Laboratory was opened in 1990. The
results of the work performed there have made BUMC a
world leader in anesthesia for liver transplantation. As
a result, Dr. Ramsay has been asked to speak and join
panels at numerous national and international medical
meetings.
Departmental
leadership
In 1989 Dr. Roy Simpson
announced his impending retirement. Dr. Michael Ramsay (Figure
19)
was appointed his successor after an interdisciplinary
search committee made this recommendation to Mr. Boone
Powell, Jr., the president of BUMC. The appointment was
then ratified by the anesthesia section. (This was a
significant change in Baylor's appointment procedure. Dr.
Simpson had been directly appointed by Mr. Boone Powell,
Sr., in 1975 while he was executive director, a procedure
essential at that time but inappropriate in 1989.)
The department had
developed professionally and increased substantially in
numbers and sub-specialization during Dr. Simpson's
tenure. Much remained to be done, however. Dr.
Ramsay's selection was a timely and inspired appointment.
The rapier replaced the bludgeon (personal comment,
B. R. Simpson, 1999).
Sedation scale
Dr. Ramsay designed a
study on controlled sedation for patients in the
intensive care unit, together with Dr. Roy Simpson in
1974 (25). In this article a sedation scale was described
that 20 years later was to become a standard
international scale known as the Ramsay Sedation Scale.
This scale is now part of routine sedation monitoring in
hospitals throughout the world (Table).

The routine use of
sedation scales in the critical care unit results in an
objective assessment and close control of the level of
sedation of the patient. The precise control of sedation
and analgesia can reduce the need for muscle relaxants
and the potential complications associated with their
administration. Sedation agents administered to a defined
clinical endpoint, as opposed to a set dosage regimen,
allows for a continual reassessment of the patient,
continuity of care, cost-effective use of drugs, and the
avoidance of under- or oversedation. The
target-controlled infusion of sedative results in fewer
adverse events, shorter stays in the intensive care unit,
and substantial economic savings.
Organ transplants
Following the successful
start of the liver transplant program, a series of first
heart and lung transplants were performed at Baylor by
Dr. Peter A. Alivizatos, with Dr. Ramsay administering
anesthesia. The first heart transplant was performed at
Baylor in 1986; the first domino heart-lung
transplant, in 1989. This was followed by the first
successful single-lung transplant and the first
double-lung transplant in Texas in 1990 and 1993,
respectively.
Pediatric anesthesia
In 1989 Dr. Ramsay and
Dr. Robert Kramer, chief of pediatrics, designed the
concept of a children's hospital within BUMC. In addition
to a dedicated pediatric operating room, the first
pediatric induction room in Dallas was constructed. A
preoperative holding area and recovery room were also
constructed on the fifth floor of the Hoblitzelle
hospital, close to the operating room. A pediatric ward
with a play area was built on the fourth floor of
Hoblitzelle Hospital with a friendly environment and
decor for children. A dedicated group of
pediatric-trained staff served both floors. A policy of
minimal parent-child separation was formulated. When
appropriate, parents could stay with their children
during induction of anesthesia and could be present in
the recovery room as they awakened.
Pain management
The demand for a
multidisciplinary pain management center was recognized,
and Dr. Ramsay chaired an initiative to set up such a
program in 1991. In 1992 Dr. Carl Noe and Dr. Robert
Haynesworth were appointed medical directors of the
Baylor Pain Center and developed a multidisciplinary
chronic pain program. In 1995 a second center was opened
at Baylor Medical Center at Garland, and the following
year another center opened to serve Arlington and Irving.
In 1997 the Pain Center was accredited by the Commission
on the Accreditation of Rehabilitation Services.
Discussion between Dr.
Ramsay and Dr. Dennis Landers, the new chairman of the
Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Management at The
University of Texas Southwestern Medical School, resulted
in an agreement to collaborate between their respective
pain programs. In 1999 Dr. Noe was appointed joint
medical director of both the Baylor and the medical
school programs.
The relationship between
Dr. Landers and Dr. Ramsay continues to be very strong. A
joint clinical-base year in anesthesia program was
started in July 1999. This program, approved by the
American Committee on Graduate Medical Education, is
another example of the close interaction between the
departments since Dr. Landers became chairman in 1995.
Continued quality
improvement
Dr. H. A. Tillmann Hein (Figure
20)
took over responsibility for the BUMC quality assurance
committee from Dr. Barry Gilbert in 1996. He made
tremendous advances in outcomes analysis by creating a
database with benchmarks against which the department's
performance can be evaluated against that of other
departments. Dr. Hein, who has an ardent interest in
supporting research and education, was appointed clinical
professor of anesthesiology at the medical school.
Anesthesiologist
groups
Dr. Thomas Swygert led an
effort in 1998 to combine the various groups of
anesthesiologists into a single group, Southwestern
Anesthesiology Consultants. This was not an easy task, as
these groups had been very competitive, and the
anesthesiologists disagreed on matters of practice
management and economics. The advantages of working
together and improving professional time use and costs
eventually prevailed. In early 1999 the groups moved into
a single set of offices. Initially each group maintained
some independence in practice patterns by creating
divisions. However, the total integration of the groups
was perceived as a possible goal. The obstetric
anesthesia group found itself unable to support the
initiative and, very early on, withdrew from the venture.
Community service
Many of the
anesthesiologists, together with anesthesia technician
Monico Solomon, Jr., donate their medical services to
developing countries. These countries include the
Dominican Republic, Belize, Mexico, Syria, Taiwan,
Thailand, and Myanmar.
Professional
leadership
Dr. Catalina Garcia (Figure
20)
was appointed to the Texas State Board of Medical
Examiners by the governor of Texas in 1991. She was the
first anesthesiologist to hold this position. In 1994 she
was appointed to the practicing physician advisory
council of the Health Care Financing Administration by
the Secretary of Health and Human Services. In 1999 Dr.
Garcia joined an advisory panel to the Food and Drug
Administration, and locally she became a member of the
Dallas Team, a group planning the future development of
the city.
In 1998 Dr. Ramsay was
appointed co-medical director of operating room services
at BUMC along with Dr. Ronald Jones, chief of surgery.
Dr. Ramsay was also elected to the board of trustees of
BUMC in 1999, one of the first 3 physicians to serve on
the board. This exciting move is a major change from the
American tradition of excluding physicians from hospital
governing board membership and will provide a new
professional perspective on BUMC's board.
Dr. Robert Parks (Figure
20)
led the medical staff into the new millennium as
president, and he continues in various leadership
positions on state and national anesthesia society
committees. The more important roles that he has filled
include president of the Dallas County Anesthesiology
Society (19831984), president of the Texas Society
of Anesthesiologists (19921993), and president of
the BUMC medical staff (19992000). At a national
level he has been a member of the professional standards
committee of the American Society of Anesthesiologists
since 1994, and locally he has been a member of the
powerful credentials committee since 1994. His
outstanding contributions to the medical profession
continue.
The department enters the
second millennium with almost 100 anesthesiologists with
privileges at BUMC.
THE NEW CENTURY
During the 20th century,
BUMC's capabilities in surgery, transplantation, and
anesthesiology have gained national and international
recognition for the medical staff and medical center.
These capabilities have been developed through the
unified efforts of a number of generations of
anesthesiologists, surgeons, and internists working in
concert. Medical staff and Baylor administrative leaders
plan to continue efforts to provide the quality of care,
teaching, and research in the fields of anesthesiology,
pain management, surgery, and transplantation that will
continue to place BUMC among the national and
international leaders in the century ahead.
Plans for the future for
the Department of Anesthesiology include the development
of an automatic electronic information management system
to increase access to patient and medical information and
enhance availability and accuracy of medical records. It
will also allow immediate and aggregated data analysis
for continuous quality improvement purposes and provide
direct cost information. One of greater challenges that
BUMC and BUMC's anesthesiologists will face during the
21st century will be providing excellence in health care
under increasing economic restraints.
Anesthesiologists in the
century ahead can be expected to play a leading role in
perioperative medicine, pain management, critical care,
and operating room management. This will allow for the
continued development of complex interventions to help
even the most compromised patients have a successful
outcome and improved quality of life. The major focus of
the Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Management will
continue to be patient safety. The advances made over the
past decades will be improved upon. In 1970 the national
mortality directly associated with anesthesia was 1 in
7000 patients; this improved to 1 in 10,000 in 1980 and 1
in 250,000 to 400,000 today. This improvement has been
the result of better training, better patient monitoring,
and more receptor-specific drugs. Continuous quality
improvement strategies will make understanding and
preventing human error a number 1 priority so that
patients can confidently undergo anesthesia knowing that
their personal well-being is secure.
The role of BUMC and its
anesthesiologists in the new century will be to be world
leaders in providing the best health care to the
community.
Acknowledgments
Significant assistance
with this manuscript was provided by Drs. Harold
Boehning, Donovan Campbell, Raymond Courtin, Bill
Epstein, Oneita Hedgecock, Roy Simpson, Law Sone, and
Charles Tandy and Ms. Dorothy Colvin. Editorial oversight
by Dr. Larry Wilsey and invaluable secretarial help from
Vickie Howard and the Baylor Scientific Publications
Office staff is also acknowledged.
Acknowledgment
The author gratefully
acknowledges the help of Ben Merrick, Louise Marie Giles
Baldwin, the Dallas County Medical Society, E. R. Hayes,
Larry Wilsey, and Diana Santa Ana.
- Porter R. Greatest
Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of
Humanity. New York: WW Norton & Co,
1998:365.
- Porter R: 663.
- Long CW. Account of
the first use of sulphuric ether by
inhalation as an anesthesia in surgical
operations. Southern Medical and Surgical
Journal 1849;5:705713.
- Bigelow HJ.
Insensibility during surgical operations
produced by inhalation. Boston Medical and
Surgical Journal 1846;35:309,
379382.
- Snow J. On
Chloroform and Other Anaesthetics.
London: Churchill, 1858.
- Cupples G. Personal
Journal, 18501876. Pat Ireland
Historical Library, University of Texas
Health Science Center, San Antonio, Texas.
- Adams GW. Doctors
in Blue: The Medical History of the Union
Army in the Civil War. Baton Rouge:
Louisiana State University Press,
1996:120121.
- Cunningham HH. Doctors
in Grey: The Confederate Medical Service.
Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University
Press, 1993:226227.
- Randall E, Cerna D. A
contribution to the study of the action of
chloroform. Transactions of the State
Medical Association of Texas
1894:201216.
- Cerna D, Wood HC. A
research to determine the action of nitrous
oxide, nitrogen, oxygen, and carbonic acid
upon the circulation, with especial reference
to nitrous oxide anesthesia. Therapeutic
Gazette 1890;6:s310.
- Cerna D. The
pharmacology of the Ancient Mexicans. Annals
of Medical History 1932:4.
- Henderson L. Baylor
University Medical Center: Yesterday, Today
and Tomorrow. Waco: Baylor University
Press, 1978:37.
- Worley JR. Nitrous
oxide in obstetrics. Transactions of the
State Medical Association of Texas
1923;18:551.
- Poe JG. Modern
General Anaesthesia, A Text Book for Students
and Practitioners of the Art of Anaesthesia.
Dallas, 1926.
- Poe JG. Explosions in
anesthesia and their prevention. Dallas
Medical Journal 1926;12:202205.
- Courtin RF.
Electroencephalograph during surgical
anesthesia with nitrous oxide, oxygen and
ether [thesis]. University of Minnesota,
1950.
- Courtin RF, Burnap TK.
Variation in the electroencephalogram
associated with uncomplemented halothane in
man. Excerpta Medica
1968;200:533537.
- Courtin RF. The
treatment of Herpes zoster from the
algologist's point of view. Dallas Medical
Journal 1981;67:132135.
- Simpson BRJ, Parkhouse
J, Marshall R, Lambrechts W. Extradural
analgesia and the prevention of postoperative
respiratory complications. Br J Anaesth
1961;33:628.
- Walling PT, Paulsen
AW, Rorech-Maleck D. A pressure and
volume-limited inflation syringe. Anesthesiology
1989;71:283288.
- Swygert TH, Robert LC,
Valek TR, Brajtbord D, Brown MR, Gunning TC,
Paulsen AW, Ramsay MAE. Effect of
intraoperative low-dose dopamine on renal
function in liver transplant recipients. Anesthesiology
1991;75:571576.
- Ramsay MAE. The use of
antifibrinolytic agents results in a
reduction in transfused blood products during
liver transplantation. Liver Transpl Surg
1997;3:665668.
- Marcel RJ, Ramsay MAE,
Hein HAT, Nguyen AT, Ramsay KJ, Suit CT,
Miller RD. Duration of rocuronium-induced
neuromuscular block during liver
transplantation: a predictor of primary
allograft function. Anesth Analg
1997;84:870874.
- Ramsay MAE, Spikes C,
East CA, Lynch K, Hein HAT, Ramsay KJ,
Klintmalm GBG. The perioperative management
of portopulmonary hypertension with nitric
oxide and epoprostenol. Anesthesiology
1999;90:299301.
- Ramsay MAE, Savege TM,
Simpson BRJ, Goodwin R. Controlled sedation
with alphaxalone-alphadolone. Br Med J 1974;2:656659.
APPENDIX
BUMC-affiliated
presidents of the Texas Society of Anesthesiologists
Joe Billy Wood, MD:
19551956
M. T. (Pepper) Jenkins, MD: 19621963
Gerald Mullikin, MD: 19691970
Harold Boehning, MD: 19781979
Law Sone, Jr., MD: 19861987
Robert I. Parks, Jr., MD: 19921993
BUMC-affiliated
presidents of the Dallas County Anesthesia Society
Law Sone, Jr., MD
Robert I. Parks, Jr., MD
Michael A. E. Ramsay, MD
Thomas W. Swygert, MD
Anthony D. Lehner, MD
H. A. Tillmann Hein, MD
|