Site Search     
Proceedings Logo
Past Issue:
Volume 12, Number 4 • October 1999
 
Arrow Bullet Return to Table of Contents


BUMC Proceedings 1999;12:259-260

The first organ transplant at Baylor
white box.gif (46 bytes)

white box.gif (46 bytes)

n a December afternoon in 1984, Dr. John Fordtran, then chief of internal medicine at Baylor University Medical Center, got “the strangest phone call.” It was from his friend Dr. Thomas E. Starzl in Pittsburgh. Dr. Starzl had just received a startling phone call of his own, from First Lady Nancy Reagan. The little girl who had just placed the star atop the White House Christmas tree, 5-year-old Amie Garrison, was in desperate need of a liver transplant. A donor was available. Mrs. Reagan wanted Dr. Starzl to perform the operation. But Dr. Starzl's own University Children's Hospital in Pittsburgh was full. He told Dr. Fordtran he wanted to do the operation at Baylor.

It would be the first liver transplant ever performed at Baylor. Dr. Fordtran had 1 hour to decide whether to go ahead with it. The stakes were high either way. “If we declined,” he says, “I think Tom would have concluded we didn't have the guts to be in the transplant business.”

Dr. Starzl was an old friend of Baylor. He has also been seen as one of the greatest technical surgeons, scientists, and teachers of our time. Dr. Starzl performed the world's first human liver transplant in 1963 and the first successful liver transplant in 1967.

What Dr. Starzl proposed to do at Baylor that December evening was no small undertaking. Amie Garrison and her parents were coming from Indiana, 731 miles away. The donor liver was in Canada, 1169 miles away. Dr. Starzl was planning on bringing 5 associates, and they were all 1070 miles away. Dr. Klintmalm, who was to initiate Baylor's transplant program in February 1985, was from Sweden, 5086 miles away. (Fortunately, he was in Dallas, making plans for the new program.) Doing the transplant at Baylor, then, would involve moving a total of 14,000 man-miles (one way).

“A large number of doctors began to accumulate in Boone's office,” Dr. Fordtran says. Boone Powell, Jr., president and CEO of Baylor Health Care System, was away from his office and not expected back until 5 pm—the deadline for the decision. The assembled doctors debated the urgent questions: “Could the people involved really get here in time to do a transplant at Baylor? Could Baylor handle a complicated case, a desperately ill 5-year-old child?”

Compelling arguments were advanced on both sides. The debate was going full steam when Boone Powell arrived. He had no idea what was going on. Dr. Starzl was on the line, awaiting the decision. Dr. Fordtran recalls, “Boone listened to both sides of the argument for about 5 minutes and said, `Well, I think we should do it.' At that point there was 100% agreement. In the end, we thought this little girl would miss a vital chance if we didn't take the risk on the downside that we might suffer if things didn't go well.”

The operation started at 6 am the next day and ended at 2:30 pm. Dr. Starzl was assisted by Dr. Klintmalm and teams of physicians from Pittsburgh and Baylor (Figure 1), including anesthesiologist Dr. Michael Ramsay. “It was actually a very hard case,” comments Dr. Starzl. “Amie had originally had a biliary atresia, but we didn't understand why her condition had deteriorated so rapidly until she was opened up at Baylor. She had a very large abscess. . . . We had to resect the abscess along with the liver.”

“At a news conference the next day,” recalls Dr. Fordtran, “Tom was asked how things went, and he said they went all right, in a typical understatement. The Baylor transplant program had been launched, and the whole world saw it.”

Amie Garrison benefited greatly from the operation (Figure 2). But she suffered side effects from the immunosuppressive drugs. In 1994, in what was apparently a teenage rebellion, Amie stopped taking her antirejection drugs.

When Dr. Fordtran followed up with Amie Garrison's family, he feared the worst, since most people who stop their immunosuppressive drugs reject the donated organ and die. He was happy to hear that despite the fact that Amie has taken no medicine for 5 years, she is doing well. She now has a healthy 2-year-old son (Figure 3).

The organ transplant program at Baylor, started by Dr. Starzl, has developed into one of Baylor's hallmarks and flagships. Twenty-one transplant fellows have trained under Dr. Klintmalm, and the 1000th liver transplant was performed in 1995.

Dr. Starzl had the following comments about the story of Amie Garrison's liver transplant.

We made a discovery in 1992 that was astounding. In 30 patients, 100% of those studied, donor cells from the transplanted organ had left the transplanted organ and migrated throughout the body of the recipient. This meant that the recipient of a successfully transplanted organ was a genetic composite, possessing part of the donor in all of the tissues. So, these beautiful women that we see, including Amie Garrison, who go to the bathroom in the morning and put on lipstick and wash their face, are actually caressing the cells of that long-dead, unknown donor, a donor that perhaps might be of a different sex or a different ethnicity. It is quite sobering, and there is a spiritual implication to the realization that the recipients are more intimate with the donors than with any other person that they will ever know or will ever have known, with only 1 exception. And, of course, the exception was their mother, for a period of about 9 months, in the womb, before they were born.